Wow two hours and 70+ posts later and the thread has...made absolutely no progress, and no one has made any effort to understand the other side, good job :thumb:
Though this has admittedly given me time to organize all the complaints and the complaints I have are.
1: Why do something if it's pointless?
2: Declumping is an unfair advantage.
3: Declumping is cheating.
Considering number 3 isn't a question, or something I'm going to be able to convince you people of otherwise let's talk about the other two.
Why do something if it's pointless? The answer is...because people do things that make no sense, most people don't think of these things in terms of probabilities or anything, it's just a simple action that the user doesn't even understand. This isn't a Pokemon problem this is a human problem.
Does declumping present an unfair advantage. I don't believe so, even if the player doesn't move the cards, they're probably going to shuffle into that point anyway to solve the same problem, and no I'm not saying this is effective either, just that it's what would probably happen, and if moving a few cards around is so detrimental then why isn't complaining about grabbing cards they're considering to get off of searches too, you wouldn't even know the difference unless they told you, or your paying a lot of attention.