Pokémon TCG: Sword and Shield—Brilliant Stars

2013-06-20 PLF Hariyama 063

Status
Not open for further replies.

waynegg

CotD Editor<br>Forum Moderator
"Before posting, please review the FAQ and follow the Guidelines provided for Card of they Day. Whereas we enjoy opinions of the cards, it is necessary to include a Brief Description for all players to understand your point of view and an optional Rating (ex. x/10). In the future, posts not using the FAQ information may be deleted and reported. Thanks, Mgmt"



[gal=54725]2013-06-20 PLF Hariyama 063[/gal]​
 
5/10

Attacks and HP are acceptable. Like Nidoking, you one shot Darkrai which is always nice. But for the same Cost, Terrakion can do the same thing with no drawback, and it's a basic, and it has 10 more HP, and it has a better first attack. That's a shame because this isn't a bad card, but it will never see play as long as we have basics like Terrakion.
 
Another card I think was a near miss.

Right now, simple is not a bad thing so long as it is not underpowered and simple.

Even with a potential shifting metagame, Fighting Weakness is rather abundant; unless another aspect of the card overrides it (like the Pokémon being represented being at least part-Flying), Colorless-, Darkness, and Lightning-Types all sport Fighting Weakness "by default". While that isn't a majority of the Types, it is a significant amount. 120 HP on a Stage 1 isn't good, but it isn't cripplingly bad; at least most decks that don't score OHKOs in general or exploit Weakness are needing a combo to accomplish the job. More would have been better, though. The chunky Retreat Cost is going to be bypassed or reduced in most competitive builds and makes it a legal Heavy Ball target, and Psychic Weakness isn't the death sentence it was even earlier this format.

So the problem is the attacks are underpowered/overpriced. Fake Out at :)colorless::colorless:) and/or hitting just a little harder would have been good, but as is it is acceptable. Pivot Throw is poor; the good news is that it hits the 90 point threshold, meaning at worst 2HKO for things that can't reduce/prevent the damage or boost their HP and a OHKO for Fighting Weak Pokémon that again, can't reduce/prevent damage or boost their HP.

:)fighting::fighting::colorless:) is expensive by modern standards; cards with similar costs have better turns and additional support, at least if they are competitive. Being a Stage 1 honestly lines up fairly well with being a Pokémon-EX; trading requiring an extra card and extra turn of investment instead of giving up an extra Prize. So hitting for 90 while upping the damage Hariyama takes by 20 is put into painful perspective when you think of Darkrai EX and its Night Spear hitting for 90 and 30 to the Bench (a beneficial "effect") for an equivalent :)dark::dark::colorless:)... plus backing that up with a great Ability and :dark: support. Pivot throw should have just required :)fighting::colorless::colorless:) and still probably hit a bit harder given the draw back; as is we should be clearing an easy 120 points of damage. At least the additional damage is applied after Weakness and Resistance... I wonder if an attack that Resistance drops to 0 still gets the +20?

Now... I called this a near miss; despite all I just said looking like a wall of text, it honestly isn't that much in the grand scheme of things. If Fighting-Types got the kind of support Darkness-Types did, it could easily turn this card from chump to champ... or at least into a contender.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top