Pokemon with a....

Discussion in 'Cards: Strategy and Rulings Discussion' started by Lord Broly, Dec 25, 2007.

  1. Lord Broly

    Lord Broly New Member

    Side Deck.

    Now does anyone else but me think this would be a good idea. Sure it
    makes it more like YuGiOh but it won't make the total matchup of your
    deck an autoloss to your opponents. For example having a Side Deck
    consistingof a Sableye CG to tech vs Blissey or a Banette/ Another
    Psychic Type vs GG. I think it could be helpful to have a Side Deck
    instead of Main Decking those tech cards that will cause your deck to
    lose Consistency.

    Any thoughts and opinions on this?

    I think this could really change the gameplay, matchups vs certain things
    and the way we build our decks.
     
  2. Scipio

    Scipio New Member

    And how do you imagine this'd work what with the fact that unlike Yugioh, we are forced to play Single Game and as such unable to tech in cards in between games?
     
  3. mcoville

    mcoville New Member

    It would also confuse the majority of the 10 and under players. I played M:TG with a side deck, no fun. Part of the challenge of Pokémon is to build a deck that can stand against all types of other decks.
     
  4. KazamBolt

    KazamBolt Active Member

    Yeah. I don't like the side deck idea at all. It takes the some of the skill out of the game and adds luck a little too.
     
  5. Mew*

    Mew* Active Member

    I don't want side decks because I don't want to have to pay for another deck. That would get too crazy. I don't want to buy anymore Time-Space Distortion. I'm so cheap, I share cards between my decks rather than going out and getting 6 Castaway for example.
     
  6. TheDarkTwins

    TheDarkTwins Active Member

    The fact is depending on how many cards you decide would be in the side deck you could compleltely change the way your deck works. It isnt a great idea, and there is not reason to add something to a game that already works so well without one.

    JMO,
    Drew
     
  7. bullados

    bullados <a href="http://pokegym.net/forums/showthread.php?

    A couple of formats ago, I made the statement that I could completely change my deck with a 5 card sideboard. I was running LudiCargo at the time, and it would have been ALL too easy to switch out the Magcargo line for more draw and search Trainers based on the matchup, or an entire TecH evolution line.

    No. I do NOT want a sideboard in Pokemon. Deck construction is difficult enough already. With even a 5 card sideboard, it would be next to impossible. This is supposed to be a game marketed to the younger age groups. How do you think they'd do with more complexity? They'd probably leave.
     
  8. Regis_Neo

    Regis_Neo Moderator

    Imagine all the hassle you'd have to go through while doing deck checks as well.
     
  9. Tagrineth

    Tagrineth New Member

    Side deck doesn't mean having 2 decks, it means having some number of additional cards outside your deck that you'd sub in for other cards for games 2 and 3 of a match (though game 1 would always return to the original deck configuration). The general idea is that if your deck has a glaring weakness and needs to dilute its strategy badly to support tech cards vs. that bad matchup, you sideboard those cards and after game 1 of a match against that opponent, you switch the tech in to improve your odds of winning games 2 and 3.

    It wouldn't make the game more like Yugioh, it'd make the game more like 90% of the other CCGs out there.

    There's just one big problem, Pokemon takes longer to play than 90% of the other CCGs out there.

    We don't even support match play in Swiss, so the sideboard would be a waste when it matters most. No point in even discussing it, it won't happen.
     
  10. homeofmew

    homeofmew Active Member

    Pokémon does have a side deck, well kinda. But you can't switch x # of cards in and out. The Pokémon TCG side deck is compiled of Cards used for translations, cards used for reprints, and Rock, Paper, Scissors cards.
     
  11. Turtok

    Turtok New Member

    Rock, Paper, Scissors cards? Can't use your hands?
     
  12. Tagrineth

    Tagrineth New Member

    Those have absolutely nothing to do with the concept of a "side deck"...
     
  13. stalkerex

    stalkerex New Member

    Eww, please never let that happen
     
  14. Darkwalker

    Darkwalker New Member

    Adding a sidedeck into Pokemon would force a few things to happen. We would have to increase the Swiss rounds to best of 3, which would also require an increase in time for each round (45 minuntes would be the minimum). A sidedeck would have to be limited to less than the 15 card sidedeck M:TG used to (it still might, I haven't played it in years) since you could drastically alter a pokemon deck with 15 cards to swap in and out. This would also be really rough on younger children in two ways; one, they would have to make a decision on what cards to swap out in a limited amount of time, and two, they would have to remember to take their sideboard cards out when they did use them.
    While I do sometimes miss having the option to add a special "hate" card for a particular deck I'm facing (or wish I could take out all my Windstorms/Cessation Crystals since my opponents deck doesn't warrant them) I just don't think Pokemon is the right game to implement this strategy into.
     

Share This Page