Results 1 to 2 of 2

Thread: Stadium from Hand to Discard Pile

  1. #1
    Avatar Creator MegaVelocibot's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2004
    Location
    Where y'see Magnemite/Porygon avs
    Posts
    4,153
    Images
    5

    Stadium from Hand to Discard Pile

    Player A plays a Stadium card of a different name to a Stadium card currently in play directly from the hand to the discard pile, not being a part of any other game action (such as Ultra Ball, Professor Sycamore, etc.) Realizing this mistake, Player A picks the Stadium card back up, and attempts to take a different game action. Player B calls a judge. Both Player A and Player B agree upon this series of game actions taking place.

    Player B says that, because the Stadium card was played, albeit incorrectly, that the intent was for the Stadium card to be played, and that the new Stadium card should remain in play. With no other game actions having taken place so far, it is Player B's choice to allow or disallow the takeback of Player A's Stadium card.

    Player A says that, because the Stadium card was never played properly, that the playing of the Stadium card was a game-play error, and that the proper reversal would be for the Stadium card to be returned to the hand, as it cannot be played directly to the discard pile. As a result, the Stadium card never entered play, and Player B should not have the choice of if it remains in play or not.

    How should the improper play of this Stadium card be resolved? Would this be a minor or major game-play error?
    New to the game? Want to learn how to improve your deck-building with just two theme decks?
    Check out I Double Theme Decks!

    I Play Theme Decks 2010 Finalist


  2. #2
    Administrator PokePop's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2003
    Location
    New Jersey
    Posts
    34,183
    Images
    1097
    In this case it is clear that the Stadium was not intended to be played as sending it to the discard is not a possible correct action.
    I would allow the rewind.
    Rules Team Member / Member of Team Compendium - The Pokemon Rulings Compendium - Co-Owner of PokeGym.net
    Premiere Tournament Organizer
    Invited to Judge every US National Championship and World Championship
    Masters Head Judge TCG World Championship 2010 - Seniors Head Judge US Nationals 2009

  3. This member says thanks for this post:

    MegaVelocibot (06/14/2017)

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •