Page 1 of 13 123411 ... LastLast
Results 1 to 25 of 318

Thread: Anatomy of a Fake Pokémon Card

  1. #1
    Administrator PokePop's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2003
    Location
    New Jersey
    Posts
    33,120
    Images
    1093

    Anatomy of a Fake Pokémon Card

    How to tell a counterfeit card from a real one.

    Fake Pokémon cards were a problem back in 1999 and 2000 but they faded away when the popularity of the game faded. Counterfeiters moved on to other card games that were hot at the time. However, since Pokémon has resurged in popularity, the counterfeiters have also jumped back on the Poké-bandwagon and are pumping out their fake product. And they do a pretty good job at it, too. At first glance, these cards look real. The images are correct. The Pokémon are what they should be. They have the right text, for the most part.

    But they are not perfect! No, far from it. In fact, if you know what to look for, they are very easy to identify and to avoid. Very easy indeed. Let's take a look at some of the things to look for on a fake card.

    Now, I could take a lot about the variance of text font and how some of the fake cards are off in their placement of some graphic elements and text formatting, but none of that is going to be useful to the average kid or parent out in some store without a real card to compare it to. No, we're just going to stick to the things that any person can identify on their own, regardless with how familiar they are with the details of Pokémon cards. I'm also going to focus on the details of the current flood of fakes. They all come from the same source because the share the same flaws. There are some older fakes and might be a few other fakes out there that don't have these flaws, but I'll cover some other general things to look out for at the end. One final note before we begin. There is a huge difference between fake cards that are couterfeits and that are meant to deceive people into buying them instead of real card versus "fake cards" that are made by fans and feature original art and text and are meant to be fun and not to deceive or rip off. Please be aware that we have no problem with such fan cards and even host a forum on our site where members can post their fan creations. Of course, these should never be sold commercially as that would infringe on Pokémon USA's rights and trademarks.

    Card Backs


    Real -=- Fake

    OK, I'm going to go back a bit on what I just said above. A person has to be somewhat familar with the details of a Pokémon card in order to identify a fake from the back, but I find it very useful to be able to do so, as it makes sorting through a large number of cards relatively easy to do. As a Tournament Organizer and Judge, I have to check a lot of cards that are used in tournaments and of course couterfeit cards are not allowed.
    So, what differences do you see in the two card backs above? The most obvious thing you may notice is the difference in color. One is paler than the other. This is not a key difference to look for, though, for two reasons. One, you probably wouldn't have a real Pokémon card handy to compare with the suspected fake if you're in a retail store. But more importantly, two, there are differences in card backs from one print run to another. While Pokémon USA tries to keep the coloring on card backs as consistent as possible, there is some variation and that makes color variation alone an unreliable method to use to determine a fake. There are two key differences here that you can rely on.

    First, notice how the blue border on the real card on the left is crisp all the way around. There is almost a line where it meets up with the swirly background image. Note that the counterfeit card's border is not as crisp. It kind of just fades off at the edge. You can especially notice this in the upper left and lower right.
    Second, look at the light blue patch just to the right of the red top of the Poké Ball. On the real card, there is a fair amount of detail there. On the fake card, it's just a blue blob.

    I can see that it might be difficult for some to notice these differences. There is a certain amount of judgement that needs to be made for these. So, let's move on the the card front and I'll show you some things to look for that take no judgement whatsoever.

    Card Fronts - Trainers


    Fake -=- Real

    Above and below are examples of a couple of counterfeit Trainer cards beside the real McCoys. At first glance, these are almost impossible to tell apart... until you know what to look for!
    I could mention the font differences. The Holon Legacy font is just about dead on perfect, but the Poke Ball font is a little bit off and most people that are experienced with the cards will pick up on that difference with little effort. But that is no use to the average person looking at the card. No, there is one mistake on these counterfeit cards that is made on every card produced by these crooks: They don't use the accent mark over the "e" in Pokémon! Take a look! Down below, they say "Each Pokemon in play..." when it should read "Each Pokémon in play..." This is a major flaw that can be used to identify almost every one of these fake cards. Heck, look at the name of the card above. "Poke Ball" instead of "Poké Ball"!!
    This is something that anyone can use to pick off these fakes.


    Real -=- Fake

    Card Fronts - Pokémon


    Real -=- Fake

    Look at the artwork on these cards, above and below. Beautiful job, isn't it? Yep, there is no way the average person is going to identify these fakes from the images used on the cards. They did a very good job of getting high quality scans of the card pictures and reproducing them. So, let's look elsewhere on the card for easily identifyable flaws. First off, we still have the "Pokemon" error. That carries over into all card text that should use the word "Pokémon". You can see examples in both the Marshtomp and Larion cards. There is also the font issue, but as noted, that won't help most people. There is one more error that carries over into all the Pokémon cards that these people produce. That is their "bloated" energy symbols. Let me explain what I mean by bloated. On legitimate cards, there are energy symbols in three areas of the Pokémon cards:
    • The upper right, after the Hit Points. This identifies what Type the Pokémon is.
    • The middle left, to the left of the Attack name(s). These tell what the energy cost of the attack are.
    • All along the bottom. These identify what the Weakness, Resistance, and Retreat Costs are.
    Energy symbols are made up of two elements; their color and their symbol. Legitimate energy symbols have a smallish symbol with a generous border around it, allowing the color to be easily seen. The counterfiet cards, on the other hand, have what I will call bloated symbols that go up to (or almost go up to) the edge of the circle, crowding the space they reside in. This is another easily distinguished error they have made.


    Real -=- Fake

    Card Fronts - Holographic Pokémon


    Real -=- Fake

    We've covered the main points to look for on most cards, but there is a very obvious error that I want to make sure people are also on the lookout for in the fakes. Take a look at the two cards above. We see the four key identifiers in this card as well: "Pokemon", wrong font, bloated energy symbols, and card back (take my word on that last one).
    This has one more error so blatent, that it alone flags it as a fake. Note the holographic foil pattern on the card to the left. If you were holding the real card, the background of the image would be shiny and the little star patterns would change and move as you moved the card. That's the holographic foil layer of the card shining through.
    The pattern on the card on the right, however, will not change or move or shine. That's because there is no holographic foil on the card! The "star" pattern is copied directly from the original card image that they photographed and then they printed that star pattern directly onto the card! Since they didn't have original art to work from, they had to use an actual foil card to copy from and so even though there is no foil on the card, it still shows the foil pattern. If you look at it in real life, there is no question that this card is not foil.

    Foil Cards


    They do make some actual foil counterfeit cards. They just don't use the right foil. If you see a gold border, that's a fake (Unless it's a Meowth from the Jungle set! That was a real promo card with a gold border). Also note that the card is a bit tilted. You will find that on a lot of the fake cards. But not always. It is one more thing to keep an eye out for, though.

    Sealed Boxes


    You can tell if a sealed box is real or fake. A real box of Pokémon cards will have the while Pokéball image and Pokémon logo shown in the circled area in the image above. If you don't see that on the front half of the shrink wrap, don't buy the box.

    Summary - What to look for

    Look for these tip offs and you can avoid being ripped off:
    1. "Pokemon" instead of "Pokémon"
    2. Card back - fades off and blob to center right
    3. Text font "off", but not always!
    4. Bloated energy symbols
    5. Holo pattern on non-holo card


    I hope that these tip-offs help keep you from getting ripped off.
    If you do come across counterfeit cards, you can inform Pokemon USA via the following method:

    Contact customerservice@go-pokemon.com with the following information:
    Card owner's name (or parent's name) and contact information
    Name and address of the store where the card was purchased
    Approximate date of purchase
    Scan of the card in question
    Scan of the packaging (if still available)
    Please make sure that it is clearly indicated in the email that you believe the card to be counterfeit.

    PUI will not replace counterfeit cards with official cards. If you contact them via email, they may request that you send the card in question to them to use as part of the investigation. If a card is mailed to them and it is legitimate, it will be returned. Counterfeit cards that are mailed to Pokemon USA will not be returned.
    Last edited by PokePop; 01/12/2008 at 09:03 PM.

  2. #2

    Great post. very timely and detailed.

    The problem of fakes is getting really bad in the LA area.

    I mainly look at the bloated energy symbols, especially the stars on the card - they are such a telltale signs. Look at any card above and you will see that the five points of the star on the colorless energy are well within the circle for a real card but are either shifted or enlarged for the fake ones. :colorless

    My daughter got an EyeClops microscope for Christmas and one of the things we looked at was the edge of the real and fake card. Well, I can tell you that both of them are made by gluing two layers (some of the older guides on spotting fakes suggest that the fake ones are a single layer cards).

    Another thing that I have seen is the frayed edge. If the fake card has been played or has been handled for any length of time, you will see clear fraying on the edges - little white marks on the edge give it away.

    As for color difference in the back, if you put the fake card in a real deck and shuffle it a bit, the fake one stands out like a sore thumb.

  3. #3
    I've even seen FAKE pokemon on there with other pokemons attacks. Like I saw a Fake Grass Eevee evo with Bellosoom's atks.
    Chris Silver
    AIM: vxt0yzruskidxv
    XBL: truKeffect

  4. #4
    some kid was trying to trade my dad a fake card yesterday. good article!

  5. #5
    A lot of the fakes I see in the UK are printed on very smooth slightly shiney card stock rather than the matt USA card stock.

    Some fakes aren't even the same physical size as the real product.

  6. #6
    Mew*'s Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2007
    Location
    Philadelphia
    Posts
    3,683
    Images
    16
    Thanks for putting this up! Good work!

  7. #7
    Also, as a very last resort and for cards that are replaceable, the famous "rip test".

    Pokemon cards have 3 layers. Most fakes have 2. The middle layer is either some black paper/cardboard or the foil. If you can somehow split the card without making it unplayable, then this is the definitive test.
    2008 North American Professor Cup Champion
    Minnesota Furious Fists Prereleases || FREE Furious Fists Win-A-Box
    Bullados YouTube Channel
    If you happen to know of a USB, clip-on microphone, please let me know. Thank you!

  8. #8
    Administrator PokePop's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2003
    Location
    New Jersey
    Posts
    33,120
    Images
    1093
    Yes, the finish to the cards is different, as is the card stock (layers).
    I didn't spend any time on those features, though, since only those of us that are very familiar with the cards would be able to detect it reliably.
    Rules Team Member / Member of Team Compendium - The Pokemon Rulings Compendium - Co-Owner of PokeGym.net
    Premiere Tournament Organizer
    Invited to Judge every US National Championship and World Championship
    Masters Head Judge TCG World Championship 2010 - Seniors Head Judge US Nationals 2009

  9. #9
    z-man's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2006
    Location
    Somewhere over the rainbow
    Posts
    1,289
    Guys... Don't buy cards from china town. The reason their cards are underpriced is because the cards are fake.
    Self proclaimed "Best Pokemon Player That is Unable to Count"
    Quote Originally Posted by MyName View Post
    I will miss MD - BW. Those were the Golden Ages of the Pokemon TCG... T_T

    SableDonk players are now my personal heroes. To your happiness and health, SableDonk users!

  10. #10
    Also, remember that buying cards from flea markets or other such markets usually means that they are fake. If you find cards really cheap, buy one and open it first before buying them all. You don't want to buy 100 packs of fake cards and find out that they are fake when you can find out that they are fake by buying only one.
    Quote Originally Posted by Mune View Post
    William Hung played this card. She-bang
    Quote Originally Posted by LibertyFigter View Post
    Pokemon National Championships: the only North American event you must walk through jail to get to.

  11. #11
    Thanks so much for posting this terrific article PokePop. I've alerted the New England community to it also...sending them here for your information!!
    Dylan L - my son
    2011 MA World Championships 8th place, US Nationals 4th place, New England Regionals 1st place
    2008 SR World Champion
    I'm the PROUD Pokemon Mum who loves scrapbooking too!

  12. #12
    Forum Moderator Regis_Neo's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2004
    Location
    AZ
    Posts
    6,349
    Blog Entries
    1
    Images
    24
    Kind of funny this was posted, I remember seeing a few fakes at the CCs I went to. Usually the text wording/print is the giveaway.
    Shameless self-promotion:

    Interested in the VGC? Want to be the best you can be? Check out my VGC Teambuilding guide here:

    http://pokegym.net/forums/showthread.php?t=158669

  13. #13
    Quote Originally Posted by bullados View Post
    Also, as a very last resort and for cards that are replaceable, the famous "rip test".

    Pokemon cards have 3 layers. Most fakes have 2. The middle layer is either some black paper/cardboard or the foil. If you can somehow split the card without making it unplayable, then this is the definitive test.
    Actually, if you look at the side hard enough, you can actually see a really thin layer of the black paper between the back and front layer of the card. This can help ID between the real card and the fake card without spliting the card.

    Well, when I browse around at eBay a few months ago, I occasionally saw some really badly disguised fake EX cards floating around (and since EX and Star cards = $$$, people who are unaware could fall into the trap). I will take the Rayquaza EX delta as an example since I saw that, the real card has "delta foil" on the Rayquaza with "delta foil" silver borders on the sides instead of the regular foil patterns and silver borders. However, the fake one looks like a normal holo card but with gold letters on Rayquaza, has the Dragon Frontiers logo on the Rayquaza art (similar to the reverse holos), and also has bloated energy symbols.

    For those who think the above is tl:dr, here's the important tip. IFF the EXs and Stars you see do not have their distintive features (or these features are just wrong), do not buy them.

    PS. You know, as someone who have collected since 1999, the counterfeiters never ceases to amuse me for the fact that the energy symbols are still the bloated variety after all these years.
    Last edited by Nu Gundam; 12/30/2007 at 06:16 PM.
    My Refs
    Professor/League Owner/Leader of Dolly's Pokemon League in Toronto

    "Is that a Punk-a-walla?" - Apparently Tata based the Nano on Pikachu

  14. #14
    Nice job 'Pop! This will help out newer players/collectors.

    Keith
    Very proud Dad of Alex & Zachary
    Judging: Regionals 2005-10 (HJ in '07-10 Masters), Worlds Staff 2006, 08-10, 12; 2007-12 Nats Judge HJ Nats JRS '08, MAs '10, LCQ JRs '10
    Mentor to many in the Sevierville, TN league, East TN PTO
    Team Rocket

  15. #15
    Quote Originally Posted by tomkite View Post
    The problem of fakes is getting really bad in the LA area.

    I mainly look at the bloated energy symbols, especially the stars on the card - they are such a telltale signs. Look at any card above and you will see that the five points of the star on the colorless energy are well within the circle for a real card but are either shifted or enlarged for the fake ones. :colorless
    I know what you mean about fakes in the LA area. At the CC I went to yesterday there was a little kid with 5 fakes in his deck. I felt really bad for him because some were his good cards, and he lost those in the middle of the match.

    Some of the fakes are really interesting. My favorite was a green charmander that had a pentagon rarity symbol.
    Quote Originally Posted by PokemansForGeeks View Post
    Liberals are tolerant of others only when their lifestyles make sense. Sorry.
    According to this logic, living solely off of welfare and having children out of wedlock with a deadbeat who runs off after the kids are born makes sense.
    Who knew?

  16. #16
    very well done pop

  17. #17
    Nice job on the article. I placed an authentic foil card in a bowl of water for a short time. It came apart in 2 sheets of equal weight. The middle dark line seen in an authentic card is likely the gluing compound used to keep these two layers together.

  18. #18
    Thanks for the great information!!!
    Winner Rancho Cucamonga Battle Roads 10/12/08-Undefeated Winner San Diego B.R. 5/31/08
    Child 10 & under: Worlds 2005, Winner San Diego Gym Challenge 2006, 33rd Worlds 2006.
    Arizona State Champion 2007 Junior Divison. AZ State Champion 2009 Seniors.
    ...cannot believe a child winning a child's card game..."

  19. #19
    here in Brazil, more specific in Sao Paulo, there's a street crowded of fake products. There were some pokémon fake decks from deoxys, FRLG, and so. The weirdest thing was the fact such decks were in portuguese (i couldnt see the cards), and written: 50 card deck.
    The price was definetly wrong: A pokémon deck is in average R$45 Brazilian Reais ($30 us dollars), but the fakes were R$5 Brazilian Reais (9 times lower, lol).
    2006 - 6th at Nats ; 2007 - Brazilian master champion
    2008 - Invite #1 from S.A rankings ; 2009 - 6th at Nats
    2010 - No Nats, but still won the only State

    The Bohwnage man from TBA

  20. #20
    I dont think you need to rip your cards to see, what happens if you rip a real card? That doesnt help you. I think a better way to find out is to hold it up to a bright light. If you can see thru it at all it is fake. This has been true for every set every made. You cant see thru real cards, but fakes you can. I havent seen a fake that I havent been able to see thru.

    Hope that helps,
    Drew
    13-14 Record Overall (35-17-6/58-37-9/0-0/0-0/180 CP) 9x BR/LC 1st, 9x CC 1st, 2x SC 1st, T4 RC 07, 1x GC 1st, T32/39th/T64/T64 NC 06-09, 4th (7-1) LCQ 07, 5x Worlds 06-10 28th 06/52nd 07/18th 08/81st 09/28th 10, 1st GAC 07, 66th ECSTS 01 D2, 36th FAT, T16 09/3rd 10/4th 12 Prof. Cup
    TheDarkTwins H/W Trade Thread - L@@K!!

  21. #21
    Good job Pokepop!

    I usually look for 2 things : the price and the energy symbols. Most fakes cant match the real ones.
    Love games? love wrestling? What about BOTH combined together?
    Try this FUN wrestling game:
    http://www.thewrestlinggame.com/wg.asp?w=526278

  22. #22

    Thanks and good job!

    Thanks and good job, Pokepop! I'll bring this to our Gym, which is hosting our Cities' next weekend.

    One Q: on the card backs, is the pair of light reflections on the real Poke Ball always circles? I think so.
    On your fake, the right-hand one is blurred out.
    In The Spirit Of The Game,
    Bitmancer
    volunteer Gym Leader (orig. WOTC, HP-on), Professor-in-Training

  23. #23

    Thanks Pop!

    Thank god for this type of post. This is not the normal junk on the random topic center. It's nice to read something new and IMPORTANT! I'll defenitly be watching my trades more closly from now on! Thanks, toxictaipan.
    Place invisible text here.

  24. This member says thanks for this post:

    CrAzEe (07/28/2014)

  25. #24
    Quote Originally Posted by TheDarkTwins View Post
    I dont think you need to rip your cards to see, what happens if you rip a real card? That doesnt help you. I think a better way to find out is to hold it up to a bright light. If you can see thru it at all it is fake. This has been true for every set every made. You cant see thru real cards, but fakes you can. I havent seen a fake that I havent been able to see thru.

    Hope that helps,
    Drew
    The new fakes you cant see through. They look a lot like the real ones unlike the old fakes where it was easy. The font and energy symbols r the giveaways. You can try the see thru test but like i have said a lot of the new fakes pass that test so dont just rely on that

  26. #25
    SLOW DECK's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2004
    Location
    NW Burb of Chicago
    Posts
    1,479
    Would it be safe to assume that Power sellers on e-bay isn't going to deal with fakes, because it would be easy for them to be busted?
    <)))))><
    Theorem: One can do just about anything, but not everything.
    Corollary: One can afford just about anything, but not everything.
    The worst thing you can do for someone you love are the things they could and should do for themselves. - John Wooden, Legendary UCLA Coach

Page 1 of 13 123411 ... LastLast

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •