I hate living in a college town. Everything is exaggerated.
The median age of people living in Tallahassee, FL was 26.3 at the time of the last full census survey. (The United States average at the time was 35.3)
As you can see, there are a LOT of people who are young, especially compared to most other cities. That means much more competition for the same jobs. Besides summertime, there really isn't any time where you ever see help wanted signs.
A good piece of advice for anyone moving to a college town: move in the SUMMER time. The job market is at least twice as open in the summertime, and there is a lot less traffic. You can get to know the area, actually have a chance landing a job, and become familiar with the city before Fall/school starts up again. Even if you don't plan on going to college, if you plan on working, summer is the time to try looking.
Tips for a successful interview:
1. EYE CONTACT. This should be tips 1-10, really. Look at the interviewer(s) directly in the eye. Don't stare, but maintain eye contact. Public Speaking says that ideally, you want to come off as extemporaneously speaking (
1 a (1) : composed, performed, or uttered on the spur of the moment : impromptu <an extemporaneous comment> (2) : carefully prepared but delivered without notes or text b : skilled at or given to extemporaneous utterance c : happening suddenly and often unexpectedly and usually without clearly known causes or relationships
)
You can see that extemporaneous speaking is exactly what you want to occur at an interview. You want to seem prepared, skilled at speaking and communication, composed and confident, but off-the-cuff and spur of the moment without a clear relationship. In order to achieve this, you need to maintain no less than 90% eye contact. Straight from the book. Eye contact says confidence, knowledge, and, again, confidence. If you're trying to convince someone of something, at least be convinced of it yourself and appear that way. If you're trying to say you're the man for the job, then be confident in that fact, and exude that confidence through eye contact.
I got in A in SPC2600- Public Speaking at FSU
2. Proper greeting. This is extremely important. Using slang or mis-naming the person's title is horrible. If the interviewer is a professor or doctor, and you call them by their first name, this may end horribly. In the South, you may want to use formality words like sir and ma'am (I do to anyone of any age appearing older than me or with an authority at the moment (a 16 year old cashier for example, I would address as ma'am/sir, despite being 21). Speak clearly and eloquently. Practice what you will greet with. First impressions are EVERYTHING. The deal is pretty much made in the first 30 seconds or not. Offering a firm handshake, addressing the individual correctly, speaking without slur and loudly/clearly is extremely important. You have to demonstrate communication skills, and this is done immediately and irrevocably.
3. Proper attire. You know about this. Pretty simple. It's better to be slightly dressed up than down. A collared shirt is a good bet. Leather shoes, or at least closed-toe shoes. Proper grooming and hygiene.
4. Punctuality. Get there early. No excuses. Period. Get there early. If he starts early, and you're on time, you're late. If he starts early, and you're early, you're on time. Get there early. If you can't show up on time to an interview, you have shown yourself to be lazy, inconsistent, irresponsible, and inconsiderate. You will never be hired.
5. Openness to change and accomadation. Small business owners are hiring YOU. Not the other way around. They want someone who can fill in specific hours, do a specific job, and follow rules/instructions well. If you come into an interview, try to be as open with your schedule as possible. The more limited your schedule is, the more difficult it will be to schedule you and have you fill in, which makes you less desirable. I like to say I have a pretty free schedule, as free as possible, and if some activities end up needing to be trimmed, I can do that on my own time instead of burdening my employer and shooting myself in the foot.
I've done hiring when working at a video store for a few years, have been hired 5 times and done many more interviews, and my father has owned 2 businesses for 10 years now, and I've gleaned quite a bit of what goes through his mind as a small business owner when it comes to hiring. If you come in with proper attire, looking and smelling and feeling great, with a firm, dry handshake and maintain 90%+ eye contact, and using good grammar and speaking to make a good first impression, you will FEEL better. You said you have a habit of only feeling settled and comfortable well into the interview, but you have to make that immediate. If you know that you're coming in with the best guns and practice, you should feel the best, and accordingly act the best and do the best. If you have the best deck, you'll feel better before every match instead of only feeling good once the game's been going.