Possible Ruling may be wrong.

Discussion in 'Cards: Strategy and Rulings Discussion' started by P_A, Feb 2, 2004.

8 league13 468 60
  1. P_A

    P_A Active Member

    I feel that in light of the Dustox ruling with Sandstorm Omastar's attack "Pull Down", and other assorted rulings about powers, that the ruling regarding Kecleon being attacked by promo Smeargle's paint referred to here:


    may be wrong. I believe that any pokemon power or body should be able to counteract any attack seeing that the steps to figure out the damage count the effects on the defending pokemon after the attack is announced and the effects from the attacker. Am I wrong?
  2. SteveP

    SteveP Active Member

    not sure what your question is, but I'm of the oppinion that "fleeting effects" like Crystal Shard MUST take precedence over "continuous effects." But, it would've been fun if Crystal Shard would've been worded to allow the attached Pokemon to become colorless PLUS it's native (or transformed) type.
  3. P_A

    P_A Active Member

    Well, actually I'm not really debating about the trainer crystal shard (perhaps I should, but I find that part of the ruling to be fair), what I find difficult to accept is that many rulings support the idea that the effect from the defending overrules the power, or attack of other pokemon (except faint attack). I can't see where Smeargle's Paint should overpower Kecleon's power. I'm just wondering if perhaps this might be a mistake. Seeing that neither card is actively used in our gym at this time, I doubt this situation would come up, but there's always that possibility. I would have to rule in accord with this ruling, but I wouldn't necessarily agree with it considering so many other rulings to the opposite.
  4. NoPoke

    NoPoke Active Member

    Smeargle's Paint attack places a colouring counter on the defending pokemon. So the effect IS on the defending pokemon much like with the Crystal Shard Tool.
  5. Jeremy Badeaux

    Jeremy Badeaux New Member

    I thought something seemed off with that ruling(the previous rulings have shown that kecleon pretty much continuously checks and rechecks to see what basic energy cards are attached).

    I have a player or two at my league that were considering making a deck that would force that ruling to come up(yes, only because it didn't have a ruling :D ).
  6. PokePop

    PokePop Administrator

    One could say that the counter was also continuously forcing the color change, too.

Share This Page