I came from The Illinios state championships today (and that is what this post is about). I need a ruling on this. Punishments: 1. I played with a 60 card deck during the entire tournament. But when I got to top 8 they did deck checks. Now my Deck is STILL 60 but my deck list states Ihave 61 cards in the deck. ( My Punishment: a 1 Game out of 3 per round loss) Is that the way is should be... or should the deck list should have been removed of one card. 2. NOw on the same note. During the same tournament, a player played with a 61 card deck during the entire tournament AND it was listed that he had 61 cards in his deck list. ( Punishment: EXACTLY THE SAME AS MINE) Isn't stated that each player MUST play witha 60 card deck at all times? Should he have not been DQ'ed for The illegal amount of cards in his deck? what would you other TO and PTO'S have done?