Pokémon TCG: Sword and Shield—Brilliant Stars

Who's right? The Prof Test or Me?

Status
Not open for further replies.

SteveP

Active Member
So, I took the Professor Test yesterday after many hours this past year of reading the rulebooks and compendium. Here's what happened:

I finish the test and know for sure that I'm going to get 100%. I finish with about 10 minutes left -- enough time to make positively sure I've answered every question correctly. At the 45-minute mark, my test is automatically submitted and returns my score of 98%. Dang, I must have misread one. When I see the question and read the "correct" answer, I'm miffed. "WHAT?" Has something changed? Immediately, I go to the rulings/rulebooks and see that my answer was right.

You ask, "What's the big deal? You passed."

Well, it IS a big deal considering that players expect judges not to make such silly mistakes during tournament rulings -- and believe me, had I ruled the way the Professor Test ruled on this question, I would've made a really silly mistake.

At the top of the Professor Test, there's a warning not to use the mouse scroll-wheel -- it might adversely affect your test score. That's a tough habit for me to break, and I'm almost 98% sure I didn't wheel-scroll. Perhaps if I was 100% sure, I would've gotten a perfect score. :wink:

A few years ago, when I took the Professor Test "cold" (no studying), I failed by one question. On that test, I also knew that my test was incorrectly scored on at least one question. Regardless of my petition to POP, I had to retake the test.

I don't know how common it is for some of you, but twice now I've gotten questions wrong that I went back and proved otherwise. So, just a recommendation from an "old man" who has learned better:

Don't study barely enough to pass. The test can "bite" you when you least expect it.:eek:

PS:

This is NOT the question, but the answer is just about as silly:

Q: Can I use Call Energy's effect to search my deck and put both halves of Ho-oh LEGEND on my bench?

A: Yes.
 
Email PCI about it. With all the other things going on with the site right now, I doubt it's high on their list of priorities. But it'll get fixed eventually...
 
The problem though is call energy cannot get the 2 pieces. Legends are just pokemon, not basics. (Unless this was the type of "error" on the test).

Email OP about the bad Q. I recall having a Q fixed on a test a few yrs ago. When rulings get reviewed/re-examined, they sometimes change. Older Qs may not be "fixed" or possibly just forgotten. There are a whole host of Qs for the exam.

Keith
 
:confused: why would this be brought up on a public forum rather than on the OP professor-only forums or via email directly to OP?

'mom
 
Or PM me the question.
Hard to say if it's wrong without knowing which one it is.
 
:confused: why would this be brought up on a public forum rather than on the OP professor-only forums or via email directly to OP?

'mom

To let others, who may have not passed because of (if it pans out) an error, know to double check their answers just in case would be the most logical reason. Everything doesn't always have to jump straight to that "The sky is falling" kind of assumed malice mentality, does it?
 
To let others, who may have not passed because of (if it pans out) an error, know to double check their answers just in case would be the most logical reason. Everything doesn't always have to jump straight to that "The sky is falling" kind of assumed malice mentality, does it?
wow, accused of a 'malice mentality' for simply asking why issues aren't brought up using the correct channels? especially when the specific question was ...quite rightly...not specified in the post?

okay...*shrugs*


'mom
 
:confused: why would this be brought up on a public forum rather than on the OP professor-only forums or via email directly to OP?

'mom
I'm not seeking to correct my test score or have the test fixed. I tried that once before without success. My intent for posting here was to provide advise to those planning to take the test.

- Watch out for the mouse scroll-wheel bug.
- Don't study just to barely pass (like I did a few years ago, and failed).
- Learn from your mistakes, even if they aren't.

There were 40 questions on the test. The one I got wrong (but didn't) stuck out the most. If nothing else, I'll never get that one wrong while judging or league-leading.
 
responded to your PM. The closest question that I could find would have been answered as the test said.
Is it possible that you misread it?
 
After PM-ing with PokePop, this is one of those "how do we interpret pre-DP card text in our post-DP world." My mind is so focused on the present that I sometimes forget how to mix the old with the new in Unlimited format.:frown:

So, I guess I DID get it wrong and the Prof Test was right.:redface:

At least I still have something to shoot for next time (study even harder to get 100%).
 
I had one question about a month ago that was not updated when the new documents went out. I emailed PCI about it, but haven't heard anything about it since.
 
There are a few unlimited questions in the test to cover league play (not all are Modified only) and local unlimited tournaments.
 
In addition, we are in touch with OP to ask that questions be removed or corrected when stuff changes. I took the test yesterday and there was a question outdated by the 9/2009 rules update.

You can PM PokePop or me or BDS on this board if you're sure you've found one that is bogus and you have the question text.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
(Insert foot in mouth -- pull it back out)

Professors, here are some lessons-learned advice:

- Read the test carefully. If you don't, you might miss the key word(s) that direct you to the right answer (which messed me up).

- Contact OP directly for corrections. Critiques about the test outside of PM's and emails are not recommended.

- I was the "silly" one to start this topic. Learn from my mistakes and don't repeat them.

SteveP
 
Last edited:
I was short one point for Professor-ship, but it turned out that my answer was correct (the question was out-dated compared to the new documents). I contacted PCI and got a reply fairly quickly, along with becoming a Professor. Guess I was lucky...
 
I was short one point for Professor-ship, but it turned out that my answer was correct (the question was out-dated compared to the new documents). I contacted PCI and got a reply fairly quickly, along with becoming a Professor. Guess I was lucky...

SteveP's issue happened a while back. It could be that the software change has allowed us more room to fix these kinds of things on the fly. :thumb:
 
Oh god, the prof test lately is a MESS. They do fix the errors you report, however - the first time after my hiatus I tried to recertify as a prof, I actually failed because of logic errors on the test. I checked everything out through compendium and had an email discussion about it, and yup...their test was that broken. They didn't give me the go-ahead, but eh...no real loss to me.

Just keep reporting the errors, they'll get fixed.

Now the fun of getting them to actually do my change of address out of the US... >_>
 
Please take a look at the last post date in a topic. An eleven month bump, or a 6 year in one of your other posts, is not needed.

A topic is dead after 30 days.

Thanks.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top