Pokémon TCG: Sword and Shield—Brilliant Stars

DeckBuilding like a CHAMPION . . .

Rogue Archetype

Moderator <br> Contest Host
I've been playing CLOSE attention to what decks winning players use and so have most of you.

However, I've ALSO been reading their story and figuring out what makes GREAT players consistent (they rarely lose REGARDLESS of what they're playing) and other "average" players inconsistent (i.e. they lose some and win some).

Take this little Quiz that I've created and RANK YOURSELF (you may keep your results a secret :wink:)

Let's have some fun:

ON THIS SCALE FROM 1 - 10 ... WHERE DO YOU RANK?

1 - The NooB (newbie) - You lose 10 out of 10 games regardless of what cards you're using. You're not even reading this because you've yet to even discover Pokegym... You're on the bottom of the totom pole, but the only way to go is up! :wink:

2 -Theme Decker You still don't know what's wrong with using a Theme deck all of the time. You've upgraded your theme deck, swapped out a few cards, and continue to play.

3 - The CacoonUntil now, you've just fiddled around with Pokemon TCG and haven't really felt that you wanted/needed to invest much time developing your game. BUT...Now, you've officially lost enough to want an entirely DIFFERENT deck. You start doing a little research, watching the good players a little closer, and asking questions. You find yourself sitting in a chair AT HOME actually trying to apply FIXES to your deck! You log onto to various websites trying to find some pointers on deckbuilding and winning decklists (and find articles from like THREE years ago.. lol). If you're lucky, you've stumbled across PokeGym and you're trying to decipher which information here is more useful than not. After much trial and tribulation, you've pieced together your first "non-theme deck" list (perhaps borrowed from an online posting of a list).

4 -THE FISH You're hooked. You're just getting SO TIRED of being treated like an autowin and you want to sit down and earn a little respect. This is like a video game now; you HAVE to figure out how to get to the next level! You're doing websearches on "Good Deckbuilding" (and you're probably pulling up Bullados' Deckbuilding 101 stuff .. LOL!)s. You're trying to make sense of it all. You want a MONSTER deck that will surprise people! You're trying to UNDERSTAND DECK STRATEGY rather than just evolving as high as you can, attaching energies, and attacking. You're trying another new list that you think may "work better" than the other "new deck" you tossed together last month. You may toss a question on the boards ("create a thread") and in your search for deckbuilding enlightenment. You're certain that you're gonna UNLOCK your potential and be a contender (you're almost embarrassed to admit to this new obsession).

5 - AverageYOU'VE DISCOVERED THE ARCHETYPE! Your new list (mostly 'borrowed' from an online posted thread) has won you games about 40% of the time!! You've started playing (have played) against BETTER competition/decks now that you've graduated OUT of the Modified THEME DECK phase. The players that were at the "A tables" are asking you if you want to battle (this is a wonderful little milestone to reach.. i know :smile:) -- BTW.. those guys CREAMATE you, but you do put up a little bit of a fight :wink:

6 - Above AverageYou're starting to experiment with other archetypes and you're trying to "FIX" your lists because they're not getting the results that people keep boasting about ("this list isn't as good as they say," You think). You're winning 50% of the time. You've got some good cards, but the "good players" are still finding a way to keep you from winning. You, still, come out of the game feeling like you had a chance of winning (not really, they were just sacrificing prizes for setup .. but anyway... )

7 -Good Player You're almost an autowin vs. a beginner player. You can beat an Average player about 80% of the time now. You're starting to feel like Hot Stuff! You've learned to anticipate the OTHER player's moves now and you've started teching in cards that help you avoid sticky situations. However, you can't build a CUSTOMized (from scratch) list that can win consistently.
You're going 3-2 at tournaments and feel like "I may never see a top cut, but it's fun trying so I'll keep showing up" You may even mess around and get a lucky Top Cut 1 out of 5 tournys.

YOUR PROBLEM is that you think that using already built lists and winning makes you "one of the better players" but you can't be BOSS until you can actually BUILD lists that work because you lack understanding of mechanics and the experience against top tier players to build a fool-proof original deck idea.

8 - A Contender - You're really starting to have fun with DECK STRATEGY and you're playing decks that you don't see everyone else playing. Pokemon is more enjoyable to you now than ever because the infinite deck possibilities has revealed itself to you. You are really gaining an understanding of METAGAME and which decks should be played. You're starting to tell the difference between people who talk and people who know (and those who know are keeping secrets!). So, you're "listening to the quiet ones that should be watched :wink:" You're that dark horse that can beat ANYBODY if your cards fall right. You haven't mastered the art of tweeking your deck to make it more consistent, but you FINALLY understand the concept of Deck strategy. When you get the build you need, nothing can stop you. Unfortunatley, you deck isn't consistent enough to beat the Boss Players who can afford to sacrifice and setup to get around your strategy. You're the kind of guy that plays risky inconsistent decks because "noone else is playing it" like TogeChomp, Magkiss, and Skittles. Decks that depend on coin flips or luck-of-the-draw. You haven't experienced playing against top tier (Boss and Pro) players enough to know why those luck-based decks are too inconsistent to be played in tourney. However, noone has teched for you and if they stall and let you catch your setup... you can win. You may top cut 1 in 7 tourneys on sheer matchup luck.

The MAIN thing seperating you from the BOSS player is experience. You just need to keep playing to see what works BETTER (not what works... but what works BEST!). You'll keep experiementing and hitting the world with strange/creative card combos that only YOU are BRAVE ENOUGH to try. You keep the tourney interesting and put creativity and fun above ratings.

9 -Boss Player You really feel like you're top tier now. People are starting to see your name on the matchup and are going "aw man... I got you this round :frown:" You're no longer an autowin for anyone; in fact, they feel like an Autoloss TO YOU!! There's still a handfull of guys that you JUST CANNOT BEAT if you're life depended on it. So, you go into tourneys knowing you have a great chance of making top cut, but you don't really expect to win the whole thing. You're top cutting more than half of the time now!!! You feel like you can beat the champion players "if you get the right cards at the right time"... you're getting to be a pretty solid player.
You FINALLY understand what a DECK FIX really is. You finally understand your PLAYSTYLE (your tendencies). You make lists better ... for YOU (you know longer play ANY list "as listed")

You've even started building your own decks (from scratch) and some of them can win (but you find yourself falling back on proven "archetypes" when tourney time comes).
Still, you KNOW there's just something missing in your game that keeps you from being the PRO player that always wins. You may even try to join a team and swap ideas with a small pool of good players in an effort to surprise the circuit with an SD or an extremely refined Archetype (i.e. teching Mesprit in Gigas w/ Palkia and cyclone to get around MewTwo techs!).

10 - PRO - If you show up, you're a threat. You either have a VERY refined version of an achetype or an insane Rogue that noone know how to defend against.
Regardless of the competition, you always top cut and make finals. When you don't, people are stunned "HE DIDN'T TOP CUT ??? WHO'D HE LOSE TO?? What were THEY running???!"
Only OTHER Pro's beat you (but they need a good setup to out speed you). Players see their starting hand, look at you and scoop because they know you've got them. You ALWAYS have a way to get to the cards you need.
Your decks run so smoothly that people wonder if you've stacked the cards (you haven't, you just build in the draw you need to get what you want when you want it). You're very seldom "whiffing" searches.
You're usually SO set up, you're merely holding back cards that aren't even necessary to win.

This is your train of thought:

Originally Posted by ryanvergel

..... Good players are good and make few misplays and have consistent lists- so their decks will function appropriately, so I fear how well they may setup, how timely it may be, and how well it will run due to a lack of misplays and fluidity of operation. I don't really fear being outplayed or manipulated- I am more concerned about the luck of the matchup, how my hand and my opponents hands are, and how the first 3 turns proceed."

HOW you win are the main are the only struggles you encounter (i.e. I can just lay this down and possibly win now, or I can play it safe and do this to win for sure in two turns)
The only thing that can beat you for sure is YOUR OWN DECK (TAILS on flips and really weird dry spells on draws that happen VERY rarely.
You pretty much know you have the match won the minute you see the matchup or the cards turn over to start the game.


WELL . . . WHERE DO YOU RANK ?

As a player, I would rank myself an 8 on a scale from 1 - 10.
(those who know me can put their own rank of me on here.. be interesting to see if you agree)

HOW DO YOU REACH LEVEL 10 - "PRO"?

Players that I LOSE to consistently KNOW what cards they need to have in their hand at the VERY BEGINNING of the game.

If you're going to be "Pro," you need to play a deck that makes sense to you.
This goes beyond understanding a card or understanding the decks strategy.

Your deck has to be an ongoing experiement that is constantly being worked on, improved upon, tweeked.

Your deck cannot be pure theory. You HAVE to play it and play it... then look for cards that can help you carry out the deck's strategy (that strategy MAY CHANGE!).

I've created a formula for success:

You MUST KNOW (by memory!) these 4 things:

the decks strategy
your opponent's decks stragies (metagame - what everyone else is playing an how to get around it)
the cards in your own deck (every single one / how many of each)
WHY each card is in a deck (yours and your oppoenents)

Finally...
YOUR IDEAL SETUP...

You need to know YOUR PERFECT STARTING SEVEN CARDS.
What EXACTLY are you trying to get your bench to look like..

And...

Your entire deck needs to be built in a way to make that Ideal Setup happen within 2 turns if possible.

I've discovered a big difference between the Average player who loses with a "great list"
and a GREAT PLAYER that wins most of the time.

A great player isn't as concerned with what YOU have as he/she is with what's not set up yet.

One last tidbit. A PRO expects to get KO'd. It's not the end of the world. In fact, he/she has already planned ahead and is actually WAITING for you to KO because what's coming next is MORE powerful!

That's all I have time to type now.. lunch is over... I'll edit more in later...

Thanks for reading my "deep thoughts" rant about being "PRO" vs. being a "NooB" :smile:
 
Last edited:
OK - I'm slightly confused. Where is the quiz I'm supposed to take?

Love your player descriptions btw.
 
I fall under the first portion of 10,
If you show up, you're a threat. You either have a VERY refined version of an achetype or an insane Rogue that noone know how to defend against. Regardless of the competition, you always top cut and make finals. When you don't, people are stunned "HE DIDN'T TOP CUT ??? WHO'D HE LOSE TO?? What were THEY running???!"
I top cut events at least 80% of the time I play, and I have some of the best lists around, and definitely rogue (Obama, Raichu/Stantler (lol) are two rogue decks I have won with, along with making other decks)
Only OTHER Pro's beat you (and they need a good setup to out speed you).
Actually, when I lose it's usually to bad players. I get donked, face a weird autoloss deck, or my deck runs cold and I get really bad draws. The majority of my losses at tournaments are to donks, not really other really good players.

Players see their starting hand, look at you and scoop because they know you've got them. You ALWAYS have a way to get to the cards you need.
I don't think anyone scoops to anyone else just based on name. This game has so much luck involved that anyone can beat anyone.

Your decks run so smoothly that people wonder if you've stacked the cards (you haven't, you just build in the draw you need to get what you want when you want it). You're very seldom "whiffing" searches.
Although deck construction is huge, luck of the draw is also a huge factor in one's setup and draws. I don't think that getting set up every time makes someone good- it makes them a donkey. Decks whiff a lot, it's about coming back from those poor starts and bad matchups that makes a good player good.
You're usually SO set up, you're merely holding back cards that aren't even necessary to win.
Ideally?

HOW you win are the main are the only struggles you encounter (i.e. I can just lay this down and possibly win now, or I can play it safe and do this to win for sure in two turns)
What other struggles can one even have lol?

The only thing that can beat you for sure is YOUR OWN DECK (TAILS on flips and really weird dry spells on draws that happen VERY rarely.
This does happen a lot. My deck always craps out on me =(

You pretty much know you have the match won the minute you see the matchup or the cards turn over to start the game.
This is definitely pretty true. I don't really fear another player at all, it's the luck and matchup I really fear. Good players are good and make few misplays and have consistent lists- so their decks will function appropriately, so I fear how well they may setup, how timely it may be, and how well it will run due to a lack of misplays and fluidity of operation. I don't really fear being outplayed or manipulated- I am more concerned about the luck of the matchup, how my hand and my opponents hands are, and how the first 3 turns proceed.
 
..... Good players are good and make few misplays and have consistent lists- so their decks will function appropriately, so I fear how well they may setup, how timely it may be, and how well it will run due to a lack of misplays and fluidity of operation. I don't really fear being outplayed or manipulated- I am more concerned about the luck of the matchup, how my hand and my opponents hands are, and how the first 3 turns proceed.

I'm gonna use that. Well stated !
 
I am pretty close to 9, I think, but not completely there yet. I topcut at like half of the tourneys I participate in, but I have yet to win anything.
 
This was an excelent read.

Only OTHER Pro's beat you (but they need a good setup to out speed you).

Not really, there are too few pro players for those to be every pro players only loss. Often, there is only a small like between top player and the majority of the rest. A good deck can crap out sometimes. If this happens and your playing against anyone close to good you lose.

You ALWAYS have a way to get to the cards you need.
Your decks run so smoothly that people wonder if you've stacked the cards (you haven't, you just build in the draw you need to get what you want when you want it). You're very seldom "whiffing" searches.

I think this is important to note. I have seen this a bunch of times, and I was considering making a thread about it. The best players get the stuff they need, cause thier decks are better and thier play is better. Not because they are cheating. The best players do well even when they are in top cut games where thier being watch be a number of people. If thier success was do to cheating, they wouldnt be able to win out events.

I think your own assesment of being an 8 player might be correct, because some of the finer details of 9 and 10 are a little off which would make sense if you hadnt gotten to that level yet.

Thanks for writing this, I enjoyed it.
 
LOL

this is the pokemon equivalent of asking if you are a better than average driver, or above average intelligence.

Anyway. On form I'm a threat, but right now I'm little more than a noob. I'm getting slow too which isn't good for tournament play :( And as for being able to read the cards: I now take an illuminated magnifying glass with me.

-----------

As to the subject of who beats you, you probably should only consider middle to late game loses. Early game there is a lot of luck that can cripple even the best players in the world.
 
LOL

this is the pokemon equivalent of asking if you are a better than average driver, or above average intelligence.

Anyway. On form I'm a threat, but right now I'm little more than a noob. I'm getting slow too which isn't good for tournament play :( And as for being able to read the cards: I now take an illuminated magnifying glass with me.

-----------

As to the subject of who beats you, you probably should only consider middle to late game loses. Early game there is a lot of luck that can cripple even the best players in the world.

The intention is SO NOT self-serving.

It's educational.

People will read MY INTERPRETAION and chime in.
Then I'll revise until we have a TANGIBLE RUBRIC for skill set.

Everyone can use it to DIAGNOSE their skill level and THEN gain some sort of guidance about how to MOVE FORWARD.

You totally missed the point / intent of the post.
 
I'm probably a 9. Every tournament I get SUPER better.

Watch out, VA! I'm climbing the ladder!

Archetype... I would put you at a 7.8, not an 8 like you say....

Why? You are a GREAT player, one of the best in the nation, if you ask me...


If you used an archetype, you would STEAMROLL EVERYONE!

My theory is that you used to run archetypes 4 years or so ago, but won so many events POP banned you from using them and you had to get your name changed and start over! :lol:
 
I'm about a 8.5-9.0. i top cut or miss top cut by a few places in almost every tournament that i actually prepare for (the only one i didnt do this was Nats last year [i started off 4-0 then got horrible hands and dropped my next 3 and drop] and Grinders last year [i went like 1-3 drop]). I built all 90% of my decks from scratch or i will take what i see that i like and change a thing here and there about to fit my playing style. I usually tend to play thinking a few turns ahead. There are some people who when i go to a tournament they dont like seeing me cuz they dont want to play me. I have yet to get first at any major tournaments but i have gotten 2nd at states and 2nd at a cities but in those 2 tournaments always losing to Eric C. (ive lost to him in every tournament except 1 prerelease lol).
 
I think I'm walking on the thin line between 6 and 7. I have Auto-Win VS beginning players, but I don't use archetypes (Café Noir addict.) and I don't like to touch them because most of the time, I really don't get them. I have to make and build my own strategies in order to play well. The only reasons I haven't made Top Cuts is because of mistakes and Glaceon LV.X.
 
Last edited:
I play with Archetypes with my own techs, but i also play rogue decks sometimes that are good. i made top cut 2 out of 3 citys i got 2nd in one and won the other, basicly nobody wants to play against any of my good decks at league, and i consistently only lose like 1-3 out of 12-15 games at league. so Rogue archetype, where would you put me at? oh and my premier rating is 1659.31 but you didn't say anything about ratings and rankings...
 
I'm a 1. :biggrin:

Seriously, why try to stroke the ego? Doesn't everyone think that they are better than they really are? It's human nature to think that one is skilled even when results really have more to do with luck. It's one of the things that stock traders are famous for and applies just as much here.

I would be SHOCKED if anyone really ranks themselves correctly with this.
 
im probally a 7.5:

7 -Good Player You're almost an autowin vs. a beginner player.
yep. never lost to a noob

You can beat an Average player about 80% of the time now. You're starting to feel like Hot Stuff! You've learned to anticipate the OTHER player's moves now and you've started teching in cards that help you avoid sticky situations.
again, playing with what might come up, instead of whats already out

However, you can't build a CUSTOMized (from scratch) list that can win consistently.
You're going 3-2 at tournaments and feel like "I may never see a top cut, but it's fun trying so I'll keep showing up" You may even mess around and get a lucky Top Cut 1 out of 5 tournys.
never got top cut at two CC's and a pre, always 3-2 or 2-2. i do build my own decks from scratch, though.

YOUR PROBLEM is that you think that using already built lists and winning makes you "one of the better players" but you can't be BOSS until you can actually BUILD lists that work because you lack understanding of mechanics and the experience against top tier players to build a fool-proof original deck idea.
i don't mesh here. i mostly look at cards, trying to find unique deck ideas, with cars that match perfecly.

8 - A Contender - You're really starting to have fun with DECK STRATEGY and you're playing decks that you don't see everyone else playing.
not really, running dusknoir & TortScep right now.

Pokemon is more enjoyable to you now than ever because the infinite deck possibilities has revealed itself to you. starting to understand METAGAME and which decks to stay away from. You're starting to tell the difference between people who talk and people who know (and those who know are keeping secrets!).
I can comperhend the metagame well, and build my decks accordingly.

You're that dark horse that can beat ANYBODY if your cards fall right.
unless their's fall perfectly:lol:
You haven't mastered the art of tweeking your deck to make it more consistent, but you FINALLY understand the concept of Deck strategy. When you get the build you need, nothing can stop you. Unfortunatley, you deck isn't consistent enough to beat the Boss Players who can afford to sacrifice and setup to get around your strategy.
I tweak well, but i could improve largely. can beat t-tar with dusky, by sacrifycing and sniping.

You're the kind of guy that plays risky inconsistent decks because "noone else is playing it" like TogeChomp, Magkiss, and Skittles. Decks that depend on coin flips or luck-of-the-draw. You haven't experienced playing against top tier (Boss and Pro) players enough to know why those luck-based decks are too inconsistent to be played in tourney.
was gonna run MagKissTran, but saw to many unlucky plays and kingdra around.

The MAIN thing seperating you from the BOSS player is experience. You just need to keep playing to see what works BETTER (not what works... but what works BEST!). You'll keep experiementing and hitting the world with strange/creative card combos that only YOU are BRAVE ENOUGH to try. You keep the tourney interesting and put creativity and fun above ratings.

go 0-4, but had fun. only gone to 2 CC's & 4 Pre's,

i think i am 7.5/7.75, what do you think?
 
This thread is a neat idea, but somewhat pointless. Most people will claim to be 9 or 10s, even if they are no where near it.
 
Back
Top