Pokémon TCG: Sword and Shield—Brilliant Stars

New Format Power Ranking

tinox6

New Member
Hey everyone! So the new format is approaching soon (fingers crossed) and I've done quite a bit of play-testing. Here are my findings so far concerning the best decks in the new format:

1. Magnezone Prime / Emboar - while it may sound clunky, it sets up quite well with 4 Cleffa and a decent mixture of Professor Oak's New Theorys and Professor Junipers. Once the deck is set up, the draw power of Magnezone Prime is game sustaining, allowing the deck to win the majority of it's games solely on sheer power. Donphan varients have given the deck the most problems, and MewGar has also been quite a tricky matchup.

2. Mew Prime / Gengar Prime - Mew Prime with Gengar Prime has been surprisingly fast and consistent throughout my play-testing. Aside from the obvious, like Seeker, the deck combo's well with a 2-2 HGSS Slowking and 2 or 3 Mime Jr. After all, if your opponent doesn't have any pokemons in their hand, you can always try to send one to the lost zone by using Slowking's power to rearrange the top 3 cards of your opponent's deck and then send the pokemon you (hopefully) find to the lost zone with Mime Jr.'s zero energy attack. Donphan, Cinccino, or anything that hits hard and fast have given this deck the most trouble so far.

3. Reshiram / Emboar - Coming in at a very close third place is Emboar Reshiram. Much debate has been had over the deck's utilization of either Typhlosion Prime or Emboar. I've gone with Emboar in my testing, and when combined with 4 Energy Returner, 3 Junk Arm, 1 Fisherman, a 3-2 Ninetails, and 1 Interviewer's Question, I just don't see a need for Typhlosion prime. The draw engine in this deck works wonders, and is CLEARLY the fastest deck in the format when all the pieces come together. My deck runs 4 Cleffa, 2 Ninetails, 4 Collector, 2 Communication, 2 Elm's Training Method, 3 Professor Oak's New Theory, and 1 Interviewer's Question. This engine has performed exceptionally well so far. A 1-1 Rayquaza Deyoxes Legend tech allows the deck to mount comebacks and OHKO pesky heavy HP pokemon. The biggest problem for this deck is Samurott or Feraligatr combined with Pokemon Reversals.

4. Machamp Prime / Reuniclus - Machamp's high HP combined with the ability of Reuniclus to move damage counters around allows Machamp to take a hit and dish out a heavy 150 damage pounding as well. Fighting tag + Seeker is a combo that is just mind blowing and game changing when properly pulled off.

5. Donphan Prime Varients - Donphan Prime variants can take a hit while dishing out fast early game KO's, which can be game devastating in this format as the KO will most likely be against your opponent's set up pokemon. Donphan can be combo'd with Blissey Prime for healing, Cinccino for type variation and quick hits, Machamp Prime for damage spread and high HP pokemon, Yanmega for the mirror match, Zoroark, or almost anything else. I would recommend playing Pokemon Reversals with Donphan prime so you can get a KO on a low HP pokemon if you need it late game. Donphan struggles against a lot of the top decks as Machamp Prime, Rayquaza Deyoxes Legend, and Magnezone Prime can all OHKO Donphan. However, as a early game attacker and partnered with the right pokemon, Donphan Prime can be a pest in this format since he has weakness advantage over Magnezone Prime, Cinccino, Zoroark, Zekrom, and Tyranitar Prime while easily KOing set up pokemon and Mew Prime.

6. Zekrom Rush - some people believe Zekrom rush will be a good play next format, and while I wouldn't disagree, I wouldn't whole heartedly agree either. Zekrom can get a donk (which sounds really funny if you aren't a pokemon player) and is one of, if not the only, pokemon to be able to achieve this next format. Combo'd with Pachirisu and Shaymin the deck can attach 2 Lightning + any other energy turn one and hit for a fast 120 damage. But what next? What if your opponent has 3 Pokemon on the field? What if Zekrom takes 2-3 Prizes but then has to deal with a fully set up field of Machamp Prime, Reshiram, RDL, Donphan Prime, or Magnezone Prime? I just don't think the deck has good mid to late game ability to hang with the top decks. Boufalant and Cinccino can even get the revenge KO, heck, anything that deals 90 damage can get the revenge KO unless Zekrom plays defenders. I personally don't see the deck being a serious contender.

Honorable mention decks: Feraligatr Prime variants (like Entei Raikou Legend, Magnezone Prime, Blastoise, and Kyogre Groudon Legend), Cinccino, Magmortar deck mill, Serperior/Renuclius, Samurott, Steelix, and Weavile/Ambipomb/Slowking all have potential.

Well there you have it, my new format power rankings and analysis. Anything is possible in the new format and that's the beauty of it!

In closing, here are a few tech cards and observations that I have seen perform well in the new format: Cleffa is the best starter IMO, Zoroark is one of THE best tech cards ever, Dual Ball is good in this format, Pokemon Reversal, Plus Power, Lost Remover, and Junk Arm are AMAZING tech cards in this format, and always wait to attach that DCE until you absolutely need to on the off chance that your opponent may have a Lost Remover in their hand.

I hope you all have enjoyed reading my analysis. Let me say at this point that I hope this can generate some positive discussion and analysis, and anyone who insults or name calls on this thread will not receive a response from me. Let's talk it up!!

- Guy
 
Is it under the "Cards: Strategy and Rulings Discussion" section? I didn't see it if it was. Man...why did the original get locked? I was hoping to start some good discussions...haha...oh well.

---------- Post added 05/26/2011 at 12:28 AM ----------

I think I've found the post under tcg news and gossip. Here's my argument to keep this one from getting locked :) : 1. The one that was locked earlier had no analysis, it was just a list of cards. 2. The post which caused the earlier thread to be locked was simply a question about what decks will be popular, which turned into a looong thread about Typhlosion Prime vs Emboar. Thus, 3. This is the first post (at least out of those other two) to actually provide some analysis concerning what might be the top decks in the next format, while looking at each deck and presenting discussion material based on play testing for more than just one deck.

That's it! I hope this thread stays open :)
 
I like the expected amount of diversity to the format. Its the first time since coming back I'm excited about deck building. I've been working on a z/p/s variant for post rotation and liking the results so far. I'm RREALLY liking the liquid burner article as I love mill decks. That one is my current pet project to find a hgss on list I like. At first I was worried about not liking the rotation, but it's growing on me as I explore it a bit more.
 
This looks pretty solid Guy. I don't see any mention about Yanmega, which I think is a pretty awesome card (though I've done no testing with it). Best Pokemon in the format seems to be Emboar. I'm also interested in testing some Lost World decks. Your right about the tech cards you mention -- I see Junk Arm as easily one of the best Trainers out there. It offers great versatility, acting almost like a Holon Transceiver for Trainer cards (which is kinda scary). Great analysis. :)
 
I like the list overall. However, I think that one card's potential has been overlooked: Floatzel UL.

This card is the MUCH better partner for Blastoise. It is much faster and easier to set up than Feraligatr. It also pairs well with Magnezone Prime. It allows you to not be so dependent on Rare Candy to get the 'Zone up and running quickly. Without having to set up Emboar, you can put in something else like Vileplume to use the Rare Candies on. It actually works pretty well. I've consistently gotten a Magnezone Prime and Vileplume up by turn 3/4, early enough to lock down most other decks.
 
Pretty much "ditto" to what we have been testing. Dont forget Serperior with donphan or Ttar is a big threat. But like indicated can be ohko with Magnezone/Boar. Also a really annoying deck is Yanmega/Jumpluff with 4 Judge/Team Rockets Trickery.
 
Awesome replies everybody!

Trican - Glad rotation is growing on you! I like mill decks as well. My BR deck is Kyogre Groudon legend mill, and it's tons of fun! Good luck with Magmortar. Diversity is a great thing, in life and pokemon :)

Erik- Thanks for the compliments! I forgot about Yanmega... :p The card will be a great counter to Donphan Prime next format. And Emboar certainly looks to be the best pokemon in the game as it pairs well with so many things...and Magnezone looks to be the best attacker in the game with RDL coming in a close second (not to mention that Magnezone is probably the best consistency card in the game), and when all three of these guys are in the same deck (Emboar, RDL, Magnezone) it's like an all-star team!

AJHawk - You have a great point about Floatzel UL. This is something I have yet to try with Blastoise. I imagine you run Shaymin as well to move the energies? And floatzel with Magnezone sounds pretty good too...I'll have to try it as well. I think missing the added power of RDL may be a disadvantage, but perhaps the added trainer lock of vileplume will make up for it. Interesting concept, I'll test it out!!

JohnnyBlaze - I've tried some TTar-Serperior stuff and it seems like a good deck, although I'm not sure how it will hang with the 6 decks listed here. Jumpluff/Yanmega disruptions sounds interesting, and I'll put it together and see how it performs. I've been meaning to put together a Jumpluff list anyway. I just worry about grass's ability to stand up to fire this upcoming season...or any card with low HP (like Pluff or Cinccino's) ability to stand up against heavy hitters
 
AJHawk - You have a great point about Floatzel UL. This is something I have yet to try with Blastoise. I imagine you run Shaymin as well to move the energies? And floatzel with Magnezone sounds pretty good too...I'll have to try it as well. I think missing the added power of RDL may be a disadvantage, but perhaps the added trainer lock of vileplume will make up for it. Interesting concept, I'll test it out!!

Blastoise doesnt need shaymin. Floazel/blastoise is faster than blastoise/gtar but blastoise/gatr is better agaainst any electric deck than floatzel/gatr because gtar cant be ohko´d easily.

i like your little article but there are some cards/decks missing in my opinion.

Stantler is a good starter for setup decks. CFF is very good in this format.

You mentioned Rdl as a tech but i think the RDL is a good deck with emboar. YOu basically needs just 3 attacks to win while your opponent needs more. there arent many cards which can ohko rdl. Besides there arent many cards which can survive an attack from rdl and indigo plateau can be used to boost rdl. There arent many counter stadiums so you have a rdl 1ith 170 hp for a long time.

slowking prime/noctowl are some draw pokemon cards. i didnt test them yet, but in some decks these can be useful

muk can be very annoying for some decks. it makes benchsitters useless and your opponents needs to play a switch. it can give you some time.

cards which can move energies like meganium or klingklang can be viable with blissey. Meganium Blissey can be a good deck despite reshiram because grass decks have good support. Celebi prime for energy attachment, sunflora for search options and metapod for tankiness (no weakness=great).
 
I've had some success with Ciniccino or Ursaring Prime paired with Ninetales and Typhlosion. Reshiram can obviously be included in the deck as a "starter" or a sweeper. Rescue Energy and DCE allow for consistent attacks throughout the game. Both fall into a pressure style deck that consistently hit for decent damage and aim to trade prizes and win a war of attrition.

Jumpluff also falls under this type of deck, but it's a bit harder to get going and sustain. There are several cards that you can pair with Jumpluff, such as Sunflora to help search your lines out. Low HP and Fire Weakness are downsides that can be addressed in multiple ways.
 
Ace - Makes sense that Blastoise doesn't need Shaymin. I'm not sure whi I thought it did ;) I agree that RDL with Emboar could be a good deck, but I think Cinccino, Boufalant, and Zoroark will give it problems. Without an Indigo Plateau, those three cards only need 3 attacks to win the game, just like RDL (of course Indigo Plateau prevents Zoroark from getiing the revenge kill). But you are right, RDL with an Indigo Plateau in play against almost anything else will be a difficult deck to contend with.

I've never heard of Blissey/Meganium, I could see RDL, Magnezone, and Reshiram giving it problems (of course the Metapod would help...), but it could be very viable! Have you tested this yet? I'd be interested to hear about its performance!

Darkwalker - interesting deck ideas. I tested Jumpfluff this afternoon and WOW it is fast...much faster than I thought...
 
Blastoise doesnt need shaymin. Floazel/blastoise is faster than blastoise/gtar but blastoise/gatr is better agaainst any electric deck than floatzel/gatr because gtar cant be ohko´d easily.

I'm not too sure that Blastoise/Feraligatr is that much better than Blastoise/Floatzel against lightning decks.

1) It is faster. It is very possible to get early snipes to disrupt the game. Taking out an early Magnemite/Magneton is a big deal.

2) You can easily tech in a counter. You can use 4 Rainbow Energy (they work with both Floatzel's and Blastoise's Poke-Powers, I checked). Then all you need to add is a 2-2 of Donphan Prime, a 2-2 of the regular Donphan, or a 2-2 of Hariyama to OHKO any lightning Pokemon. Or you can tech in a 2-2 Zoroark. All of these options can allow a solid water build to keep up in the prize exchange. It is certainly doable. Since these techs can be used in either Blastoise/Feraligatr or Blastoise/Floatzel and Blastoise/Floatzel is a bit quicker and more forgiving (IMO), BlastZel is my personal favorite.
 
Awesome replies everybody!

Trican - Glad rotation is growing on you! I like mill decks as well. My BR deck is Kyogre Groudon legend mill, and it's tons of fun! Good luck with Magmortar. Diversity is a great thing, in life and pokemon :)

Erik- Thanks for the compliments! I forgot about Yanmega... :p The card will be a great counter to Donphan Prime next format. And Emboar certainly looks to be the best pokemon in the game as it pairs well with so many things...and Magnezone looks to be the best attacker in the game with RDL coming in a close second (not to mention that Magnezone is probably the best consistency card in the game), and when all three of these guys are in the same deck (Emboar, RDL, Magnezone) it's like an all-star team!

AJHawk - You have a great point about Floatzel UL. This is something I have yet to try with Blastoise. I imagine you run Shaymin as well to move the energies? And floatzel with Magnezone sounds pretty good too...I'll have to try it as well. I think missing the added power of RDL may be a disadvantage, but perhaps the added trainer lock of vileplume will make up for it. Interesting concept, I'll test it out!!

JohnnyBlaze - I've tried some TTar-Serperior stuff and it seems like a good deck, although I'm not sure how it will hang with the 6 decks listed here. Jumpluff/Yanmega disruptions sounds interesting, and I'll put it together and see how it performs. I've been meaning to put together a Jumpluff list anyway. I just worry about grass's ability to stand up to fire this upcoming season...or any card with low HP (like Pluff or Cinccino's) ability to stand up against heavy hitters


good thread overall but yanmega is not a good donphan counter. Every good Donphan will be playing ruins of alphs
 
I'm not too sure that Blastoise/Feraligatr is that much better than Blastoise/Floatzel against lightning decks.

1) It is faster. It is very possible to get early snipes to disrupt the game. Taking out an early Magnemite/Magneton is a big deal.

2) You can easily tech in a counter. You can use 4 Rainbow Energy (they work with both Floatzel's and Blastoise's Poke-Powers, I checked). Then all you need to add is a 2-2 of Donphan Prime, a 2-2 of the regular Donphan, or a 2-2 of Hariyama to OHKO any lightning Pokemon. Or you can tech in a 2-2 Zoroark. All of these options can allow a solid water build to keep up in the prize exchange. It is certainly doable. Since these techs can be used in either Blastoise/Feraligatr or Blastoise/Floatzel and Blastoise/Floatzel is a bit quicker and more forgiving (IMO), BlastZel is my personal favorite.

No. Rainbow energy works with blastoise but not floatzel. In your hand, rainbow energy is not a valid target for floatzels power. It is a valid target once in play, for wash out, however.
 
No. Rainbow energy works with blastoise but not floatzel. In your hand, rainbow energy is not a valid target for floatzels power. It is a valid target once in play, for wash out, however.

Ah thanks, I guess I miss read it. It does not really effect the situation though. Just requires a bit more planning during the game.
 
AjHawk - Love the tech idea of Zoroark in Blastoise/Feraligatr (or Floatzel). Zoroark is great for a OHKO on Magnezone Prime and this can easily be achieved in a deck which utilizes energy accel. Would you run PlusPowers in Blastoise in order to get a KO on a 110+ hp active pokemon??

The cheating bidoof - I agree in premise that ruins is a good card in Donphan builds...however, I just don't think Donphan is strong enough to stand on its own as a deck. I would rather play a switch and bring up Cinccino and a PlusPower to get the OHKO on Yanmega...even if you don't have the PlusPower, just earthquake Yanmega once then use switch for Cinccino to get the KO. Like I said, I think Ruins is a great card and one that MUST be played in any deck that centers primarily on Donphan Prime, but therein lies the issue. In my opinion, I think DOnphan needs a partner, and Yanmega should be taken care of by that partner.

---------- Post added 05/26/2011 at 09:49 PM ----------

Also, don't forget Yanmega Prime's ability to snipe a benched Cleffa! Yanmega/Jumpluff is surprisingly fast and potent in this format!!
 
AjHawk - Love the tech idea of Zoroark in Blastoise/Feraligatr (or Floatzel). Zoroark is great for a OHKO on Magnezone Prime and this can easily be achieved in a deck which utilizes energy accel. Would you run PlusPowers in Blastoise in order to get a KO on a 110+ hp active pokemon??

I could see the use of PlusPower in Blastoise/Floatzel. However, I do not use them in my list. I just focus on getting a fast set up and sniping the bench. There are bench sitters for every deck that can be taken out.

Magnezon varients: Take out the Basics/Stage 1s quickly.

Reshiram decks: Take out Ninetales/Shuckle or OHKO anything in the active slot.

Zekrom: Take out the Pachirisus and Shaymins/

Donphan: Just run it over do to weakness.

LostGar (a very difficult match up): Take out Mr. Mime, Mime Jr. Spiritomb, Mew Prime.

Machamp: Set up fast and take out the Basics/Stage ones.

Speed is the name of the game for Blastoise based decks. Which is why I like Blastoise/Floatzel. Every piece needed to run is searchable, except Rare Candy. However, you only need one Rare Candy to attack turn two. Whereas, in Blastoise/Feraligatr, you need two Rare Candies to attack turn two.

In addition, I run 3 Pokemon Reversals in my current list. They really help in the several matchups.
You can get to those benched Pokemon that could be OHKOd if active but have enough HP to survive a turn of sniping on the bench.

---------- Post added 05/26/2011 at 08:57 PM ----------

Oh and, right now I actually like the 2-2 Hariyama or 2-2 regular Donphan better. They can OHKO both Zekrom and Magnezone without PlusPower. Yes, they will get returned KO'd, but so will Zoroark. In addition, Zoroark can only OHKO Magnezone Prime not Zekrom.
 
Well, maybe they don't have enough energy :). I think I have 17 energy in mine...18 is probably safer. The deck must have 7 lightning in it in my opinion.
 
Back
Top