Pokémon TCG: Sword and Shield—Brilliant Stars

Normal Foils - unplayable?

Status
Not open for further replies.
This problem has existed since the days of Base Set. It annoys me that they simply can't find a way to print foil cards that don't bend. At the very least, there should be nonfoil versions of every card (like there were in the days of Jungle & Fossil).

Living in Florida, the humidity bends my foil cards noticeably. If I left a card near an open window, it would take one day for it to curve into a half-circle. The card becomes stiff, like it has two legs. No joke!

With this in mind, here comes the ultimate dilemma: is Organized Play really going to hold players responsible for the fact that their own company's cards are bent into oblivion?

Idealistically, I'd hope not. Realistically, though, I wouldn't be surprised if Nationals top cut will be littered with awkward Dark Machoke proxies standing in for Reshiram, Emboar, et al. If they did it with reverse holo Deoxys cards, I wouldn't be surprised if it happened again with these.
 
Some of mine are the same way. Maybe setting them by a de-humidifier would help? Personally I just shuffle them against the bend then stick them between a couple of my TCG binders for a few days. (Albiet these things are extremely heavy.) Also I think keeping them lower to the floor helps; hot air rises so it's cooler lower down.
 
With this in mind, here comes the ultimate dilemma: is Organized Play really going to hold players responsible for the fact that their own company's cards are bent into oblivion?

Idealistically, I'd hope not.

Apparently you haven't read the Penalty Guidelines recently.

Examples of Marked Cards: Major include:

  • All of the Basic Pokémon in a player’s deck are parallel holo, causing a slight bend down the center of the card. This creates a pattern which allows the player to identify Basic Pokémon when the cards are face-down, at rest.
 
Best way to straighten anything out is to set it under some heavy books for a day or two.
Even Justin Beiber? Anyways, I just leave them in a binder under my other binders in a stack and that normally works and doesn't scratch the card at all like removing the books would.
 
@Chairman Kaga:

Instead of updating the rules to blame the players why not just fix the issue? Players shouldn't have to pay more money/trade more/etc. for a reverse foil version of a card just because the regular foil becomes so warped. You think they would've learned their lesson after the Deoxys foils and to some extent, the Regigigas sleeves.
 
@Chairman Kaga:

Instead of updating the rules to blame the players why not just fix the issue? Players shouldn't have to pay more money/trade more/etc. for a reverse foil version of a card just because the regular foil becomes so warped. You think they would've learned their lesson after the Deoxys foils and to some extent, the Regigigas sleeves.

Have to agree with this.

It's not a players fault that cards become warped as drastically as they do. When I was at some of the Black and White PRs, I pulled multiple holos that were already warped. Even putting them in a sleeve didn't help matters, as it was still apparent that that card was, in fact, a holo. It's not the players fault by any stretch when a holo is coming out of the pack already warped. It can only get worse from there if they don't know what exactly to do.

After the awful Deoxys holos, I would've thought the same thing, that they would've known better. This has been an issue for as long as I can remember, save for the Base Set to Skyridge cards. I don't remember there ever being much of an issue with those (heck, I've had some of the old metal energies from Neo Genesis, and the old Wizards holo energy, and I've never had issues with them).

I mean, I'd like to give TPCi the benefit of the doubt, since they did sort of fix the issue involving reverse holos from the HGSS cards. Remember the HGSS base set? Those Reverse Holos CURVED. We still saw that for sets like Unleashed, and undaunted, but, Triumphant seemed to correct the problem iirc. Call of Legends seemed to have the best results in actually producing playable reverse holos, at least, to my knowledge (...yeah, I know, something good about the worst set in the history of pokemon ;x).

I just hope that Black and White holos down the road are attended to. That, or, I'd like to see non-holo versions printed again (I think the former is far more likely, which, I can understand that).
 
Yeah, some of mine are definitely bent as well, trying to get them to flatten out by throwing them under books too, but yeah...this is the first time I've had this problem to any significant degree, kinda sucks quality seems to be going downhill...

That or who knows, maybe it's best to just avoid first run productions of the cards, so no more prereleases then...
 
Apparently you haven't read the Penalty Guidelines recently.

I have read them before, but thanks for giving me another chance to read them.

Since somebody else has taken up one objection to your point, I'll take up another one that's in the details of what I said: "bent into oblivion." By saying "into oblivion," I was referencing Hatter's point that normal holos (not RH) are so bent that they may be unplayable. I guess what you said could be used to refute my aside point about Deoxys RH cards, but all I was angling at with my rhetorical question was whether or not there comes a point when P!P can't blame players for their parent company's inability to print cards.

Again, I'd hope not. IMO, regular holos should have never existed from the beginning, and it should have always been reverse or nothing...Maybe it's not too late to change that? :lol:
 
Have you guys tried putting the cards in a binder? I put all my B&W holos in my monster binder, and now none of them have any bends or anything, and they did before.
 
Didn't realize b/w had bending/curving issues. I haven't noticed any such problems and I've gotten booster boxes, tins, prerelease packs, etc and all seems to be fine.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top