Shiny Noctowl
New Member
I've decided to make a CaC contest. In each round, I will post the guidelines for the card. Contestants will have 3 days to submit the card here. At the end of that time, I will score the cards and the top half (rounded up) will move on to the next round, until there is a single winner. Cards will be scored as follows:
Picture (10 points)
5 - Description (Is the description of the card's picture satisfactory to visualize the illustration?)
5 - Relevance (Is the picture of a situation that the Pokémon could reasonably be expected to be in?)
Stats (25 points)
5 - HP (Is the HP an amount that is reasonable for the Pokémon's evolutionary stage and general strength?)
10 - Weakness/Resistance (Are the Weakness/Resistance to types that the Pokémon should be weak to/resist? Is damage increased/decreased by a reasonable amount?)
5 - Retreat Cost (Is the Retreat Cost reasonable for the Pokémon's size/weight and Speed stat?)
5 - Flavor text (Is the flavor text relevant? Is it a similar length to the flavor text on real cards?)
Poké-Power/Poké-Body (15 points)
5 - Relevance (Is the Poké-Power/Poké-Body an ability that the Pokémon could reasonably be expected to have?)
10 - Fairness (Is the Poké-Power/Poké-Body good enough, without being so good as to break the game?)
Attacks
10 - Relevance (Could it be reasonably expected that the Pokémon would use the attacks on the card?)
20 - Fairness (Are the attacks good enough, without being so good as to break the game?
Back to back posts merged. The following information has been added:
To join, simply post a card for this first set of guidelines.
Round 1: Rotom
Picture (10 points)
5 - Description (Is the description of the card's picture satisfactory to visualize the illustration?)
5 - Relevance (Is the picture of a situation that the Pokémon could reasonably be expected to be in?)
Stats (25 points)
5 - HP (Is the HP an amount that is reasonable for the Pokémon's evolutionary stage and general strength?)
10 - Weakness/Resistance (Are the Weakness/Resistance to types that the Pokémon should be weak to/resist? Is damage increased/decreased by a reasonable amount?)
5 - Retreat Cost (Is the Retreat Cost reasonable for the Pokémon's size/weight and Speed stat?)
5 - Flavor text (Is the flavor text relevant? Is it a similar length to the flavor text on real cards?)
Poké-Power/Poké-Body (15 points)
5 - Relevance (Is the Poké-Power/Poké-Body an ability that the Pokémon could reasonably be expected to have?)
10 - Fairness (Is the Poké-Power/Poké-Body good enough, without being so good as to break the game?)
Attacks
10 - Relevance (Could it be reasonably expected that the Pokémon would use the attacks on the card?)
20 - Fairness (Are the attacks good enough, without being so good as to break the game?
Back to back posts merged. The following information has been added:
To join, simply post a card for this first set of guidelines.
Round 1: Rotom
- It can be any of Rotom's 6 forms.
- It can't be LV.X.
- Its name can't have any prefixes or suffixes (For example, "Charon's Rotom" or "Rotom G" aren't allowed).
Last edited: