PokeGym Gurus - These Guys know their stuff!

Discussion in 'Guru Deck Challenge & Strategy Topic Discussions' started by Rogue Archetype, Jan 25, 2011.

  1. Rogue Archetype

    Rogue Archetype Moderator <br> Contest Host

    WHO REALLY KNOWS WHAT THEY'RE TALKING ABOUT ?

    Whenever you respond to "Guru Challenge" topics in the PokeGym Strategy forum, you are creating an opportunity to earn Guru points .

    Some of the World's best Pokemon TCG Players visit the PokeGym.
    It's time to share your knowledge and help each other [/I]become stronger players.[/I]

    Note: Don't forget about the NEW players!

    LET'S BUILD!

    POINT LEADERS:

    Note: These points were compiled from the following threads:


    MagnezonePrime Deck Challenge - Click Here
    FeraligatrPrime Deck Challenge - Click Here
    TyphlosionPrime Deck Challenge - CLICK HERE

    jjkkl = 7 Points

    cfourcoltsfan = 6 Guru Points
    Vegeta_ss4 = 6 Guru Points
    Barkjon = 6 Guru Points

    chase4787 = 5 GuruPoints
    AyameHikaru = 5 Guru Points
    flash2351 = 5 Guru Points
    Rainbowgym = 5 Guru Points

    DarkWalker = 4 GuruPoints
    Box of Fail = 4 GuruPoints
    PhazonElite = 4 GuruPoints
    Elite 4 Allen = 4 points

    Melee Mewtwo = 3 Guru Points
    Scipio = 3 Guru Points
    Hatter = 3 points
    Mama_Luigi = 3 Guru Points
    Baroness Meena = 3 Guru Points
    Lucario aura wielder = 3 Guru Points

    ShadowGuard = 2 Guru Point
    Darkmot = 2 Guru Points
    Kayle = 2 Guru Points
    MrSmiley Pants = 2 Guru Points
    DoomScizor = 2 Guru Points
    Tagrineth = 2 Guru Points
    thisguy - 2 Guru Points
    Alex2k - 2 Guru Points
    LegendCallerL - 2 Guru Points
    Dual_Draw - 2 Guru Points
    chase4787 = 2 Guru Point
    Bullados = 2 Guru Points

    kwisdumb = 1 Guru Points
    Amphachu = 1 Guru Points
    Nugget = 1 Guru Points
    gallade = 1 Guru Points
    Roarkiller = 1 Guru Points
    GameStoreGrump = 1 Guru Points
    StormFront = 1 Guru Points
    Da 'Fish = 1 Guru Points
    loudkirbyking = 1 Guru Point
    Electrode Twins = 1 Guru Points

    __________________

    FYI - We're not going to entertain the issues of whether points were rewarded faily or not.
    This is a way of recognizing people who are willing to share creative and competitive ideas.

    If your Guru Challenge responses were not deemed as 'useful,' please read some of the point-earning responses and adjust your approach.


    The goal of Guru Points is to make people feel good about sharing ideas.
    Note: Simply stating the obvious may not be worthy of earning Guru Points.

    Note: The list may be updated weekly, so don't fret if your points don't add up on a daily basis :smile:

    Guru Points will be available in select threads throughout the Strategy and Rulings Forum.
     
    Last edited: Mar 16, 2011
  2. what do guru points do?
     
  3. jeffrey123

    jeffrey123 New Member

    Nothing. Absolutely nothing. Have fun getting your points guys!
     
  4. Kayle

    Kayle New Member

    Wow, someone's bitter about not having their Pokemon know-how on display so people know to take him seriously. :rolleyes:

    But seriously, that's what they're for - to keep a running record of who provides useful advice to incoming players, and/or who know what they are talking about.
     
  5. Rogue Archetype

    Rogue Archetype Moderator <br> Contest Host

    I beg to differ.

    1. They give you something to do. You give good answers to posts, you get Guru points as a thank you knod.

    2. People become encouraged to compete/contribute to see if they can top the list.

    3. The result is the forum gets packed with great information.

    4. Top scorers go on to be "GURUs."

    5. The overall spirit of the forum becomes one of fun, comradery, and sharing. :thumb:​

    We're considering giving people a custom title under their name if they can accumulate an insane amount of Guru Points (but that's only at the discussion level right now).

    Anyway, what it REALLY does is adds a little 'something-fun-to-do' when you come to the computer.

    Last time I actively did GuruPoints, the board was on fire for a hot minute (then I got overwhelmed with keeping up with the points!).

    This time, I'm going to designate "Guru Topics" just so I can manage to read and reward those who want to "play."
     
  6. Vegeta ss4

    Vegeta ss4 Iron Chef Leader

    Rogue, this is a great idea. I obviously will not be on this list due to Navy life and always working, but I think this can help that idea I presented to you a while back.
     
  7. raw19

    raw19 New Member

    Most interesting. Incidentally, what would be considered an insane amount of points?
     
  8. DJGigabyte

    DJGigabyte Forum Moderator

    Do only players get Guru points?
    Or will there be threads for collectors available?
     
  9. Rogue Archetype

    Rogue Archetype Moderator <br> Contest Host

    Very interesting question.

    I'm mostly asking "strategy" questions that have to do with decks, combos, and Spirit of the Game.

    but, NOONE is excluded from contributing answers and earning Guru Points.

    You simply find a thread with "GURU" in the title and jump right in. :smile:
     
  10. Rogue Archetype

    Rogue Archetype Moderator <br> Contest Host

    Points are updated as of January 30, 2011 (8:50 p.m. EST)
     
  11. gallade

    gallade New Member

    I think 10 points should give the title, junior guru, 20 points guru, etc.
     
  12. Rob-GAJP

    Rob-GAJP New Member

    R.A , While I fully agree with the spirit and goals of Guru Points, I believe there is nothing wrong with a little incentive component to motivate great players to share their knowledge, and also offer them some good exposure to showcase their status as Gurus. So why don't you chat with folks like Pop or Big Daddy and get help from PCI to enhance your program with things like -

    1- the Top Guru of the month gets XX Great Prime Card , or 10 Packs, or equivalent ..
    2- The Top Guru of the season gets a booster box ...
    3- the top Guru of the quarter gets to have a 30 min chat with XX ( insert your top 10 player name here, provided they agree .. ) to exchange ideas and thoughts on decks and strategy ..
    4- The top 5 Gurus are always in display in the front page of the Gym
    5- The top Guru gets to write a front-page article that is ensured to be published ...

    Hopefully you get the point . That will motivate people more to get Guru points, and will give more Stature to being a top Guru .. I'm sure there are tons of more ideas to insert here. I think the ultimate goal should be to reach a point where being a "Top 5 Guru" at the Gym gives you stature and recognition at league and tournaments by everyone, and this will spark more quantity and quality of contributions into the Gym.

    Hope this helps. Great initiative.
     
  13. pokemon99

    pokemon99 New Member

    Rob, I believe that while you have a valid point, being a Guru is NOT to compete to see who is the best, it is to try and get people to be more active in this community. I feel that with what you are doing, you are basically saying it is a competition to get the most guru points.
     
  14. Vegeta ss4

    Vegeta ss4 Iron Chef Leader

    It is a fun competition, and maybe more is to come after this guru stuff. Perhaps a collaborate deck analysis like they used to do.
     
  15. Elite_4_Allen

    Elite_4_Allen New Member

    Hopefully I can rise up in the ranks of the guru... :D
     
  16. ShuckleLVX

    ShuckleLVX Active Member

    If I may make a suggestion -

    Glancing over these topics, there's lots of good information in them, but they're going to get drown in the current of new threads. Assuming these keep rolling out for awhile, would it be worth having a sub-forum to sneak them into? I'm not sure if that's within your power as a moderator, but it would keep us from losing them.
     
  17. chriscobi634

    chriscobi634 New Member

    My only question is who determines who gets how many points?

    I've seen a couple post from the people that have higher points and their decks list aren't that great:
    http://pokegym.net/forums/showpost.php?p=1911706&postcount=3

    Then some that have a good deck idea but don't many points like this one: http://pokegym.net/forums/showpost.php?p=1911693&postcount=2

    I read in your "grading" system that you give out more points to ideas that might actually work in this metagame. Do you honestly thing that getting 2 Stage 2s and a Stage 1 fast enough to compete with this T2/T3 format?
     
  18. Vegeta ss4

    Vegeta ss4 Iron Chef Leader

    Or get an update.
     
  19. Rogue Archetype

    Rogue Archetype Moderator <br> Contest Host

    The "grading system" is absolutely subjective. That's why I don't tag prizes and stuff on them. The points are just a way of saying "thank you for taking the time to post ideas."

    That being said, I do try to have SOME sort of rhyme-and-reason to the system.

    The first example used a list that I've actually seen work (3-2 in tournament). The author also gave some details as to HOW to run the list (that's VERY important). It wasn't a brilliant list so it did not earn a 3 or 4, but the premise and detail were there, so it will help people get started if they want to try the idea out... so it got a 2.

    The second example had a couple of lists, but with very little instruction/detail about how to run them. Just posting lists only helps people who have the ability to create and play their own. So, it gives experienced players a head-start on the idea, but those who need more guidance will spend hours trying to figure out why each card is even in the list to begin with.

    So, when it all comes down to it, I guess I'm looking at the "teaching/coaching" ability of your posts IN ADDITION TO the lists themselves. (very consistent with what I do in the "I Play Theme Decks" contest). I guess that's just how my mind's rubric is designed to work.. lol
     
  20. Rogue Archetype

    Rogue Archetype Moderator <br> Contest Host

    I'm only updating once per week.

    That way I can sit down, compile, and post in one big batch.
    (usually will be on Sundays)

    Also, people won't tend to change their posts based on what someone else 'got' and can earn scores on the merit of their own ideas/thoughts.
     

Share This Page