I think they should switch the positions of "mentor and noob" for each generation. Like Brock was mentoring Ash so now Ash has become the master and should mentor another noob while Brock goes and retire or something. Then that cycle just continues on and on for each new generation.
Where in the world did Brock (and Dawn) go?
- Thread starter HRPrime
- Start date
- Status
AlmightyGoldenGarchomp
Member
ooh, I have an idea. How about they make an actual developing plot line? There. Problem solved 
PokemonTrader
Active Member
My suggestion....
1. You can make 2 series - one for old school fans who want to reminisce about the past and want to watch Misty, Brock and Ash get lost, and lost, and lost
2. Bring back characters - though there would be a big feud about who to bring back... Oak, Gary, Misty, Brock, May, Max, Drew, Harley, Dawn, Ritchie, Tracey etc....
3. Don't watch the show if you are going to complain that "So and so isn't back" etfc
4. They just have a show with JUST Ash to see how his training goes, and in the end, has a big tournament with all his rivals. This can bring back Butterfree, Primeape, Haunter and all his pokemon who he left or gave away.
1. You can make 2 series - one for old school fans who want to reminisce about the past and want to watch Misty, Brock and Ash get lost, and lost, and lost
2. Bring back characters - though there would be a big feud about who to bring back... Oak, Gary, Misty, Brock, May, Max, Drew, Harley, Dawn, Ritchie, Tracey etc....
3. Don't watch the show if you are going to complain that "So and so isn't back" etfc
4. They just have a show with JUST Ash to see how his training goes, and in the end, has a big tournament with all his rivals. This can bring back Butterfree, Primeape, Haunter and all his pokemon who he left or gave away.
I heard that Butterfree died...
Ash is the main character. Brock like everyone else is a side character, thus easily replaceable. I understand if he's your favorite character but personal preference doesn't affect whether a character is truly still useful in the show.
The last time Brock truly felt relevant was the Johto saga. Once the Hoenn seasons began the focus of the show shifted to Ash being slightly more mature and to May and the Contests, and then to Dawn and finally Iris and Cilan.
Even though Brock stayed for Hoenn and Sinnoh, was was practically invisible for most of it. Other than flirting with girls and explaining Ash's battles to May and Dawn, he very rarely did anything else. His role had diminished greatly to the point where he hardly even battled or captured pokemon anymore.
If they had actually kept Brock interesting like he was in the first few seasons I may have liked him more and missed him on the show. But after DP I was just ready for him to go.
Otaku
Active Member
Here's the thing:
You're acting like there was this deep storyline.
There wasn't. Well, most of the time, anyway.
All the characters are easily replaceable. It is a cookie-cutter plot. At best you can claim that the latest game's cast are not replaceable while their game's story remains to be told... but Ash isn't from the newest game.
Brock wasn't as important as I would have liked; this is part of why I found myself watching the show less and less. His leaving just cemented it for me; I only watch the show when it is convenient, and as I lack cable that is quite infrequent. Getting back to the point, making Brock relevant was the writer's responsibilities; they failed, just like they can (and probably will) fail to keep any of the cast culled from the Black & White games relevant.
tl;dr: All the characters are easily replaceable in Pokémon. I enjoyed Brock's character. You didn't. End of story.
You're acting like there was this deep storyline.
There wasn't. Well, most of the time, anyway.
All the characters are easily replaceable. It is a cookie-cutter plot. At best you can claim that the latest game's cast are not replaceable while their game's story remains to be told... but Ash isn't from the newest game.
Brock wasn't as important as I would have liked; this is part of why I found myself watching the show less and less. His leaving just cemented it for me; I only watch the show when it is convenient, and as I lack cable that is quite infrequent. Getting back to the point, making Brock relevant was the writer's responsibilities; they failed, just like they can (and probably will) fail to keep any of the cast culled from the Black & White games relevant.
tl;dr: All the characters are easily replaceable in Pokémon. I enjoyed Brock's character. You didn't. End of story.
I was watching this and i was wonderng does Paul ever show up again after the big sinoh tournament.( damond and pearld season 13) oh and also berry
and how bout dru from when may was in the show
---------- Post added 12/19/2012 at 09:14 PM ----------
y is it when ever ash starts a new journey he is just turning 10
he cant be 10 forever
he forgets u have to battle then catch a pokemon
his pokemon suck and are very weak( pickacu)
and how bout dru from when may was in the show
---------- Post added 12/19/2012 at 09:14 PM ----------
y is it when ever ash starts a new journey he is just turning 10
he cant be 10 forever
he forgets u have to battle then catch a pokemon
his pokemon suck and are very weak( pickacu)
Last edited:
- Status