Pokémon TCG: Sword and Shield—Brilliant Stars

WEREWOLF XV: Pokemon Wars: GAME END: TOWN WINS!!!!! See Post 2547 for Final Update!

A couple things. First, ninja'd by jellyfisher while I was fact checking. Second, unfortunatly, the comm. link is like redados', "no comment.":frown: Lastly, I have compiled a chart of all of the nighttime afflictions such as burns and bruises, and have figured out a few roles by process of elimination. The question for the town would be if I should reveal roles that are most likely town, or make the wolfs do it themselves.
Thoughts?
 
Scottistru said:
A couple things. First, ninja'd by jellyfisher while I was fact checking. Second, unfortunatly, the comm. link is like redados', "no comment.":frown: Lastly, I have compiled a chart of all of the nighttime afflictions such as burns and bruises, and have figured out a few roles by process of elimination. The question for the town would be if I should reveal roles that are most likely town, or make the wolfs do it themselves.
Thoughts?
Click to expand...

Personally, with the ship breaking apart and us possibly being on a time limit to win the game, I'd say post the list. However, I would also like to hear the other players opinions as for whether or not to have you post it.

I have another, longer post up in another tab I'm putting the finishing touches on after I post this.
 
1464

Scottistru said:
A couple things. First, ninja'd by jellyfisher while I was fact checking. Second, unfortunatly, the comm. link is like redados', "no comment.":frown: Lastly, I have compiled a chart of all of the nighttime afflictions such as burns and bruises, and have figured out a few roles by process of elimination. The question for the town would be if I should reveal roles that are most likely town, or make the wolfs do it themselves.
Thoughts?
Click to expand...

I'd say post it, because as it is, like Piplup said, we're on a timer here. In addition, if you took the time to do so, it's probably a safe bet that the two or three other anti-town roles have done so as well.

The loss of them reading the info if they hadn't is offset by the gain we get from a broader discussion, and the quickness in which we need to move from now on. We have... 4 rooms remaining?
 
1465
jellyfisher said:
I wouldn't be so sure of that. Why would AT put in the tattoos if all they did was incriminate someone? Especially if we could find out they were harmless by killing one of the tattooed people. I think there's more to them. But until we know more, we should not assume that they are meaningless.
Click to expand...

Just guessing, thats why I put a question mark. My comments to cabd's post are in Italics.

cabd said:
In the Barracks, one man slept, hoping he would be safe as he closed his eyes to the world, next to him a small toolbox.
I take it this is AAM? Should be. Agreed.

In the mess, only one inhabitant spent their night. Tinkering with gadgets and machinery, their sense of safety being placed in solitude was mistaken
Also, this could be AAM.

To me, this says that this is a team. We know of at least one other, from the day one kill with Magneboar. I’d speculate that we have one team for each set of player alignments, so a total of five teams, each with 3~4 members? That’d leave room for wolves and one or two indies, I think.
Ultimareda was also on Magneboar's team. I'll say more about that team later in the post (Though I'll post again if I forget to..)

This plus the breakup later makes me wonder if the rest of the ship won’t blow up slowly, and every room we visit is a crapshoot for survival.

I have a verryyy bad feeling that this is correct. I'm thinking we are on a clock before the ship completely breaks apart, and that anybody who picks the room(s) that are going to break apart as their place for the night, then they will be killed.


So the team size was five. The alpha dead makes four, a leader and three goons. Makes sense. We can probably safely assume Magneboar’s team is 5 (now 4) members or less.

Again, Magneboar's team also had Ulitmareda on it, who is now dead. With your earlier theory about multiple "teams" combined with the number of remaining players, I would say there are 3 to a team.


Oh shi…… Yeah, that’s got to suck. It’s possible that other rooms will suffer this fate in the coming nights/days.

Have a bad feeling this is correct.


Looks like both sets of “bad guys” want to kill the positive jedi first, then worry about each other? It seems like we’ve got a triangle of fighters, and only one can win. I think…. Not really sure. It could be that the sith and the empire can ally. Who knows?

So we have a 3rd AND a 4th party...? Confusing...Very...Confusing. All I know is we need to start making some very good lynches.


Once again I wonder if the empire can control ship destruction, and possibly the mechanic role off-sets this? All kills have been helpful to the empire, so…..
Hoping there is some way to offset it, or we're in trouble. I don't like the idea of random death traps...

In the Engine Room, a man walked in. This was his favorite spot, and he had something he planned on doing. However before he took more then five steps a barrier enveloped him and prevented him from advancing any farther. Frustrated at failure, he sat down to wait out the night. He would be unable to sleep however. He could have sworn he saw Emperor Palpatine looking at him, trying to figure out how to get to him. However that might have been just the wind and the shadows playing tricks on him. In the shadows, a man waited for a target that never came.
I wonder if this is linked to the odd premonition on the top of the update.
To what are you referring to? (At the top of the update)


Alright. In conclusion, I think it is worthwhile to try and debate who is a good lynch candidate.

And yes, 4 Rooms
Click to expand...
 
cabd said:
In the Engine Room, a man walked in. This was his favorite spot, and he had something he planned on doing. However before he took more then five steps a barrier enveloped him and prevented him from advancing any farther. Frustrated at failure, he sat down to wait out the night. He would be unable to sleep however. He could have sworn he saw Emperor Palpatine looking at him, trying to figure out how to get to him. However that might have been just the wind and the shadows playing tricks on him. In the shadows, a man waited for a target that never came.
I wonder if this is linked to the odd premonition on the top of the update.
To what are you referring to? (At the top of the update)


Alright. In conclusion, I think it is worthwhile to try and debate who is a good lynch candidate.

And yes, 4 Rooms
Click to expand...

1467

I'm talking about this line from the update:
A creature, sat cross-legged on his bed, and seemed to be watching something far away. He suddenly jerked as if seeing something unholy, but soon returned to peace.
Click to expand...
 
King Piplup said:
1465
cabd said:
In the Barracks, one man slept, hoping he would be safe as he closed his eyes to the world, next to him a small toolbox.
I take it this is AAM? Should be.
Click to expand...
Agreed.
Click to expand...

I agree with both of you. This person is almost confirmed to be AAM. However, I don't agree with you on this...

King Piplup said:
cabd said:
In the mess, only one inhabitant spent their night. Tinkering with gadgets and machinery, their sense of safety being placed in solitude was mistaken
Click to expand...
Also, this could be AAM.
Click to expand...

In the first quote of AT's update, it says that he is going to sleep. But in this part of the update, it says that he is in the mess, and tinkering with the machinery. If it really was AAM, then why would AT have said that he was going to sleep earlier in the update? It also says that the person is tinkering with gadgets and machinery. But in all of the other updates with AAM, it says he has his tool kit out, and is working on the machinery. So the inhabitant in the mess must have been Akane. If you want more evidence of that, just look in the other updates that clearly show the wookie. They say that he "tinkers with the machinery" in most of them. And that is the same thing this person is doing.
 
jellyfisher said:
I agree with both of you. This person is almost confirmed to be AAM. However, I don't agree with you on this...



In the first quote of AT's update, it says that he is going to sleep. But in this part of the update, it says that he is in the mess, and tinkering with the machinery. If it really was AAM, then why would AT have said that he was going to sleep earlier in the update? It also says that the person is tinkering with gadgets and machinery. But in all of the other updates with AAM, it says he has his tool kit out, and is working on the machinery. So the inhabitant in the mess must have been Akane. If you want more evidence of that, just look in the other updates that clearly show the wookie. They say that he "tinkers with the machinery" in most of them. And that is the same thing this person is doing.
Click to expand...
What I meant was that either of the two people could have been AAM. I do think the first person mentioned in the update is most likely AAM though, just threw it out there that the other person also had a chance of being AAM.
 
Alright, It seems the general consensus is to post the table, so I will do so. The list breaks down the affliction, people inflicted, possible role(through desriptions in update and death), and possible cause. Bold meens confirmation by death, and underline means confirmation by process of elimination. Confirmations are color coded, and I've left out tatoos and votelessness, as they add no information.
Part one of my list. I will need a bump for part 2
Night 1​
Affliction: Beaten and Tied
People Inficted: Napolean/Jason
Possible Roles: Salamence Trainer/Crazy Scientist
Possible causes: 2 men/Armored pack

Affliction: Bruised
People Inficted:Gallade/E4A(Me)
Possible Roles:Group/Sneaking Man(confirm by me)
Possible causes:Rod person/Wookie

That was exausting; these tags take forever; and this short post took 30 minutes. As soon as I get a bump I'll start day 2.
Once again, please bump.:biggrin:
 
bump for ya! great to see this type on info,though I'm still not 100% sure I understand what you mean with the labels and stuff and how this connects to roles, but am in anticipation to find out!
 
While we wait for Scottistru, I'd like to hear from AAM about which of the two people he was. At this point, it won't hurt to, right? Correct me if i'm wrong.

I'd also like to hear what Cardz had to add.
 
Agree with cabd's points, which also is the last post I read.
King Piplup said:
bump for ya! great to see this type on info,though I'm still not 100% sure I understand what you mean with the labels and stuff and how this connects to roles, but am in anticipation to find out!
Click to expand...
OK, I re-read it, and now somewhat more understand what it means, but a full breakdown might help.
 
Basicly, the color show who goes with what role, based on discriptions in the update. For example, in night 1, by process of elimination, Napolean must be the Salmence Trainer, who was tied up by 2 men, as shown by the colors. Hope this explains everything.
Night 2​
Affliction:Bruised
People Inficted:Z-man
Possible Roles:Murkrow
Possible causes:???

Affliction:Burned
People Inficted:Gallade
Possible Roles:Group
Possible causes:Blow Torch

Not much for night 2, so I should be able to post one or 2 more nights worth before I have to go do homework/sleep. When I'm done I'll post a summary of the nights and whose roles they reveal.
Bump please
 
Scottistru said:
Basicly, the color show who goes with what role, based on discriptions in the update. For example, in night 1, by process of elimination, Napolean must be the Salmence Trainer, who was tied up by 2 men, as shown by the colors. Hope this explains everything.
Click to expand...

The logic you are using would suggest that Napoleon is the Rosarade trainer, not the Salmence trainer. But besides that, I haven't noticed any mistakes in your logic.
 
Wow, Scottistru. This is looking really good so far. Keep up the good work.
I'd advise you to post what roles are revealed first, for one reason. If you were hit with any sort of delayed silencing role (we know at least one was out there, easily could be two; and if it works like the other one, more people posting would end you) then the rest of your list would sit useless and you might get killed overnight.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top