Pokémon TCG: Sword and Shield—Brilliant Stars

Don't Read This Post: PS's Random Pokemon Blog

So I've been thinking a lot lately; about the past season, between nationals last year and this year; about some (posts) I've made that I regret; about things that have been said about me. I have been on both the giving and receiving end of some pretty nasty stuff.

And I have been thinking about the 'gym - an odd little creature, in that such a large majorty of the PTCG community comes together here.

And in regards to the 'gym, I've been thinking about how it seems like almost every thread I click on here has either arguing, flaming, ganging or complaining.

I've been thinking about some players who take the game so seriously that they lie, cheat, backstab, etc. Not all. But some.

And I've been thinking about where we go from here.

I've long held the belief that the PTCG will only survive as long as the demand for Pokemon as an entity survives. The cartoon, the games, the movies, it is all tied together. Without those outside forces bringing pokemon fans into the fold, where do the new players come from?

Because it seems to me that there are only a very, very few people who are going to say to themselves, "hey, I think I'll play Pokemon!" if they don't already have a basis for understanding and LIKING pokemon on a broader level.

And those players who do randomly pick up the game...why would they? Some, maybe, because of their friends. Others, many more, I'm afraid, for the prizes.

And that really scares me.

My mom said something to me not too long ago that really struck me hard. She's been playing the game for a little over a year and really started to enjoy it and enjoy the time she spent at tournaments. But she said to me, and I paraphrase some of this, that she was starting to feel like Pokemon wasn't fun anymore.

She said to me that everything was fine when she was a poor player. Everyone was nice to her. But when she started winning more...when she started competing, that changed. The attitudes of the teenagers she played changed, and the attitudes of the adults she played changed. She even got acused of cheating.

That makes me sad. And I know that many will say, "well, if its not fun, don't play." Or, they will say, "maybe you need to take some time off away from the game." Still others will offer that if you can't take the heat, you shouldn't dace by the fire.

But I disagree with that. I disagree with the whole attitude behind that train of thought. I feel like our community, in some ways, has come to expect poor behavior and immaturity; I feel like we've come to accept that as normal, and to expect kindness and compassion as something only a few special people are going to personify. And isn't that also true of our society as a whole? The ME generation? GenerationI?

And what makes me even sadder is knowing that I, for a little while, fell into the trap. That I, for a while, was exactly the same as what I'm speaking out against.

I've been thinking a lot, lately. About many things, as you can see. But all of these seemingly random thoughts lead to a single place.
I don't understand why we can't be nice to each other.
What is on the line here? A $7,000 prize?
Is that really worth all of the bitterness? Is that worth all of the smugness I feel from the game's top players? Is that worth all of the resentment I feel from the games lesser players?

I don't know when the Pokemon Trading Card Game will end. I worry about it, but then I realize one thing: it doesn't matter.

As important as any of us might try to make ourselves at any given time, we cannot control what happens to this game. We are powerless, in that regard.

So I've made a decision to change the way I think about being involved in this game. I've decided to get back to the reasons why me and my family started.

We actually like Pokemon, and are not ashamed of it. We like the cartoons. We like the games. We think Pikachu is cute, not annoying. And we miss Misty.

We like traveling together and spending time together.

And yes, we like competing and trying to become a pokemon master.

But for pete's sake, people...it shouldn't be a matter of life or death.

So my goal this season is to simply be nice to people.
My goal is to compete, but to do so with a certain amount of respect.
My goal is hold myself to a higher standard than I've been holding myself to.
Because I can't control what happens to this game.
Nor when the season starts.
Nor when the whole shebang is over.
But I absolutley can control my own actions even when it is difficult to do.
And I'm posting this not because I hope to change minds but so that others out there will know that there is at least one like mind.
 
Last edited:
*stands up and cheers*

With your permission, I'd like to move this to the Featured Articles forum...please LMK if that's okay...

'mom
 
I don't understand why we can't be nice to each other.
What is on the line here? A $7,000 prize?
People don't change on command, and things in the PTCG will probably stay the same. As long as greed exists, things like cheating, stealing, and lying will also exist. Since the begining of time this has been true.

She said to me that everything was fine when she was a poor player. Everyone was nice to her. But when she started winning more...when she started competing, that changed.
The mentality of that is when you're a bad player your no threat to anyone else and people like you because you lose and that's what they want from you. But, when you get good at it, people are afraid of you, and others use their fear as an excuse to create false accusations in order to get over their fear by any means neccessaryamd when they can't get over it their fear turns to hate and they get angry for losing to someone that doesn't seem "cool" or experienced as themselves.

Loved this article.
 
The game is only fun when it's extremely competitive. If I'm not constantly trying to win, I would lose interest. However, I've never disrespected myself or anyone else by cheating. Cheating in any form, from stalling to abusing holes I know exist.

I don't really see myself changing too much this season. I'm going to judge more, but aside from that, I think I've always been a good and decent player who's never done a disrespectable thing to other players.

The best thing to do is show that winning on a lie isn't worth it. If I only won Worlds because I cheated or lied or abused the system, it wouldn't be as satisfying to me.

I want to be the best, not the one who wins.
Hopefully the best player happens to be the winner, but that definitely isn't the case. I won't ever hold winning over being the best, though.

I don't resent or disrespect other players for stalling- it's a choice. It's the system that is at fault- it refuses to correct itself, so good players will use mistakes to their advantage, and I can't really say that's a bad thing.

It's 5am, and I can't think very straight. UGH.
 
I agree with you PS. I was asked not too long ago if it was alright if that person could PM me. He said that sometimes people tend to be offended when people they don't know contact them. Less and less people show common courtesy unfortunately, but that's the time when you need it most - to be able to counteract the poor manners flow. Let's all take a moment to appreciate others, ask for a little less and give a little more. Believe me, it works. So I guess I'm one of those same thinkers phoenixsong. Keep it up, and with others, maybe you can make a difference.
 
Sorry, but you don't seem to be the person who refused to give me explanation after a trade in which you received my cards and refused to send me the cards you were supposed to send.

If you want to be nice with the people, it would be good to talk with those people, if you think there are problems. And it's not correct to ignore them, hoping they'll forget everything about you.
Phoenix, i have always said that i'm not sure about anything, i don't think you are a ripper (you have many, many, many refs) but if you are the person i read in this topic, a person that i want surely to meet soon, please don't be fool and open a dialogue in which we can clarify about what happened to us.

Don't talk about big things if you are the first who does things against the Spirit of the Game.
 
Pokemon is marketed as a kids game. How long can a kids game continue to sell? The game won't last forever, though things are looking up right now. Enjoy every moment you have with it, cuz you never know when it'll end...
 
PhoenixSong, I've met you in person and bought from your store many times in the past year or two. When I met you, you seemed like a very nice guy, and it was a pleasure to meet you like it's a pleasure to add a nice new stamp to a stamp collection. I liked your post, and I agree with most of it if not all of it. I wish you best of luck with your new goals, whatever they may be, and hopefully I'll meet you again in the future.
 
Havoc said:
People don't change on command, and things in the PTCG will probably stay the same. As long as greed exists, things like cheating, stealing, and lying will also exist. Since the begining of time this has been true.

I agree.
But I address this point:
Just because there are prizes on the line doesn't mean we should accept poor behavior (as a whole) as the normal; we shouldn't look at good behavior as the deviation.

Trying to win is fine - but we seem to be a society (in the game and outside) which has come to the conclusion that winning with honor doesn't matter. Maybe this is the way it is in the modern age. Maybe we live in a world where we have become so isolated that we have no responsibility to our honor or to our neighbor.

I'd like to think that's not true, and that in activities such as Pokemon, we should expect people to go above and beyond in terms of sportsmanship.

As an aside, I played competitive baseball for 15 years. I traveled, literally, all over the world. And in that time, in the thousands of games, I met few opponents who were as genuinely mean as many people I've met in this game.

Back to back posts merged. The following information has been added:

ryanvergel said:
The game is only fun when it's extremely competitive.

That may be true for you, but it is not (and should not) be true for the population as a whole.

As a rule, it is also the most fun for ME when it is extremely competitive.

But 'extremely competitive' doesn't have to mean downright nasty.

(that's not directed at you, Ryan).

It doesn't have to mean trying to put your opponent down.
It doesn't have to mean trying to demoralize your opponent or make them feel small.
And it certainly doesn't have to mean getting so upset that you'll leap up from your chair cursing when you've made a misplay (as I've seen some people do).

Its not so much a question of ethics as it is a question of manners, and I guess I'm pleading for more of them.

If I'm not constantly trying to win, I would lose interest.

I'm not saying you shouldn't be constantly trying to win.
I'm saying that we shouldn't be so concerned about being "better" than our opponent.

When we focus on our game and on what we can do we will be in a place where we can do good things.

Back to back posts merged. The following information has been added:

P_A said:
Less and less people show common courtesy unfortunately,

Yep.
I think we live in a world that actually devalues common courtesy; it is seen by many as a sign of weakness or eccentricity.

Back to back posts merged. The following information has been added:

andceo said:
Don't talk about big things if you are the first who does things against the Spirit of the Game.

Your post is off topic and very disrespectful.
And besides, this situation was investigated by the tribunal.
A LONG TIME AGO.

Back to back posts merged. The following information has been added:

Prime said:
PhoenixSong, I've met you in person and bought from your store many times in the past year or two. When I met you, you seemed like a very nice guy, and it was a pleasure to meet you like it's a pleasure to add a nice new stamp to a stamp collection. I liked your post, and I agree with most of it if not all of it. I wish you best of luck with your new goals, whatever they may be, and hopefully I'll meet you again in the future.

And the same!
There are a lot of great people in this game.
 
Last edited:
This season I really think we will see the two types of players separate themselves.

The group of hard core players trying to win a trip to Worlds will diminish. There are only so many players who can dedicate in the US the level it will take to get to Worlds, in any age group.

It will take doing well in SO many cities, States, Regionals, Battle Roads and Nationals, that I can see having to compete in just a vast number of events, with one or two poorly placed losses knocking you right out of the running.

This will force people to reevaluate why they play, and determine if they are playing for fun, and if not, why not?

The opposite will be true as well....those that believe they have a shot at the ring will feel pressure to do what is needed to get the ring. One of the invites from the US.

Do you run after your major competition, and try and knock them off, or do you stay away, winning titles at events you know your big competitors will not be at to pick up easier Premiere events points.

In short, I can see the competitive side of the game getting better AND worse this year.

Nationals...if there are Trips on the line, could be one of the harshest tournaments in the HISTORY of the TCG.

Don't think the judges and PTOs haven't been making themself ready for this onslaught...we have our plans, at least I do. Players are expected to act a certain way, respectul of other players and the event.

If you are not...

Vince
 
I agree with Vince.

I think that the overall number of super-competitive players will decrease this year, but the nastyness level of those that remain will likely increase.


Wether I am right, and wether that will be good for the game is yet to be seen.
 
we seem to be a society (in the game and outside) which has come to the conclusion that winning with honor doesn't matter.
It's sad to say, but honor really doesn't matter to a lot of people now a days.
Honor isn't something you can hold or feel, and it's that type of thinking that makes people want more than they can have by any means available. Material posessions and what you have and don't have is all that matters.
 
It's human nature for people to lie and cheat when they're at the big show, if you could call competitive Pokemon that. Look at Pete Rose, Bill Clinton, Rush Limbaugh, etc. I just find it humorous that people backstab over Pokeman. rofl.
 
PokemansForGeeks said:
It's human nature for people to lie and cheat when they're at the big show, if you could call competitive Pokemon that. Look at Pete Rose, Bill Clinton, Rush Limbaugh, etc. I just find it humorous that people backstab over Pokeman. rofl.


I dont understand this at all Pete Rose bet on baseball, Bill Clinton commited Purjury, but what did Rush Limbaugh do?
 
Nice article Jim! I guess I have gotten spoiled a bit when watching the top players in the Southeast compete with a great deal of "gentlemanness". Sure, they love to win, bit they will do so in a fair manner. Seeing the Nances, Jake B, Jim F., the Schnells (when they travel over), the Hills, the Millers, the Craigs and Silvestros and several others I know I am forgetting....when they play, it is top notch and you know it will be well-played and done in a decent manner. I guess having a 'Gatr in the house patrolling the sidelines and running the show will help!

I hope we will continue to see good play and manners this year, since I will be primarily judging again (as long as Jeff will have my help!) This season will indeed be a VERY interesting one!

Keith
 
Awesome thoughts and I share them completely. I see the same mechanics (play for fun = having fun and switch to competing = tight faces, secrecy, anger, resentment and the nasty side of competition) at our gym. I don't run the risk of being a serious competitor (hate that part) but I sure don't want to quit the having fun part. A second league? League tiers?
 
Back
Top