Cyrus
Iron Chef - Master Emeritus
I don't understand the obsession with Super Scoop Up. What exactly are you using it for, the Murkrows are going to get OHKOed more than half of the time and playing it just to pick up an Absol is a waste.
I originally played some Roseanne's but I was have trouble getting Murkrows out quick enough so I switched to Mentor. I am thinking that Dual Ball is probably the play now...
I have also considered dropping the DRE and Scramble all together and playing Crystal Beach, but it doesn't even seem to help much againsthttp://pokegym.net/forums/newreply.php?do=newreply&p=991204
The PokeGym - Reply to Topic Blissey because you are slow enough as it is and the Blissey will just get enough energy on it to OHKO Murkrows.
Here is the elite idea behind Pokedex. Although you must play 60 cards in a deck, many times I think decks would rather play LESS cards than that if given the option, to increase consistency. Pokedex achieves this effect except for T1.
Re SSU: the last poster summed it up: its main function is to reuse Umbreon*. However, why waste four spots in your deck to sack two of their cards on average? I agree that it just simply isn't that good.
Re Rosanne: I think a mix of Rosanna and Dual Ball should make that problem negligible.
Re DRE and Scramble VS Crystal Beach: I really, really like that idea, actually. Just because it doesn't help vs Blissey much doesn't mean it _won't_ help vs the rest of the field, right?
Re Pokedex: it is elite logic to play Pokedex under the right circumstances, but this deck is not perfect enough to warrant four "deck thin" spots. Ask yourself: if Honchkrow consistently loses to the most popular Pokemon in the format (Blissey), then why would it want to use those four spots for Pokedex, as opposed to...say...a general solution to that one bad matchup?