Pokémon TCG: Sword and Shield—Brilliant Stars

Is this legit?

Thanks, I was looking for that.
May remove inapporiate comments, huh?.. Well I think I figured out his magic trick. Also, it looks like a great deal of his Positives are for "prompt payment". In other words, as a buyer, not a seller.

TheAtma said:
Negative Review: "poor packaging. Seller strange. does not want to return the money."

Reply: "buyer thanked me when art arrived then ate the picture and refuses to return ite"

Weird is putting it lightly!
Click to expand...

Personally? I like where he responds to yet another removed comment...
Buyer refused to return item and lost buyer protection case. sent him xact item
Click to expand...

And they're all like" yeah?"
USPS 03073330000019375198 PROVES RETURN - BUYER DID WIN CASE & PROTECTION REFUND
Click to expand...
That one made my day.
 
Last edited:
Okay this is getting ridiculous. The Charmeleon looks really bad in the upper left corner, and the Pikachu he added is "off" imo. The white square isn't quite right, it is angled very slightly. I'm not buying his story, and I'm not buying his cards. At this point I'm as skeptical as they come.
 
cbd1235 said:
Okay this is getting ridiculous. The Charmeleon looks really bad in the upper left corner, and the Pikachu he added is "off" imo. The white square isn't quite right, it is angled very slightly. I'm not buying his story, and I'm not buying his cards. At this point I'm as skeptical as they come.
Click to expand...

Come on he has his carmander and carmeleon for a reasonable $1,200. Who wouldn't want that? after all it is"rarer then charizard".
 
It was a mistake doing the evo card.
Too hard to wipe away around the jagged edges of the evo box.
 
Well we can't say that with certainty but there's overwhelming evidence that he's a phony. Just start with his troubling feedback.....both as a buyer AND as a seller. The guy is shady to say the least.
 
He seems very strange... He does have a other shadowless cards up for sale. We'll see if they get relisted without pictures.
 
cbd1235 said:
Okay this is getting ridiculous. The Charmeleon looks really bad in the upper left corner, and the Pikachu he added is "off" imo. The white square isn't quite right, it is angled very slightly. I'm not buying his story, and I'm not buying his cards. At this point I'm as skeptical as they come.
Click to expand...

I am glad someone else noticed the top left corner. And good observation Pop! It wouldn't make sense to see the evolution box but have no illustration. And $1,200....:nonono:
 
Oh man, this guy is too much.

I love the circle of people who keep giving positives to him, over and over. There also appears to be more then a few users buying & selling merchandise between just him and each other, all with 100% feedback and no avatars. Not to mention the multitude of different users giving the exact word for word feedbacks.
Oh and the ones that keep calling him "brother"...
 
I'm OK with seeing the evo box. I just don't think that it looks "clean".
But I'd like to see a better image to be sure.
 
S_Cullers said:
Asked for close up. S/He responded. Side note when doing the s/he at the beginning of a sentence do I need to capitalize the H?
Click to expand...

I think the correct way would be to type "He/She responded." You're supposed to spell out both fully, and I believe he goes first, or at least it usually does. And then it just seems appropriate to capitalize both because if you take one out, the other still has to be capitalized.
 
Lovin 'Buy Now, Pay Later' and it's built in protection right about now :)

Just by virtue of the Charmeleon being posted he let us know these are fake. The picture I saw of the sheet with these had only commons. Charmeleon isn't a common. Even if the evo corner were perfect, it screams FAKE. Really disappointing.
 
Last edited:
If charmeleon really was blank i would think the evo picture would be blank too.
Still think if the illus. was really blank i would think it would be gold not white.
 
crazypokemon said:
If charmeleon really was blank i would think the evo picture would be blank too.
Still think if the illus. was really blank i would think it would be gold not white.
Click to expand...

Neither of those points are concerns.
Each element of the card design is independent of any other element.
One could be left out and another included in any legitimate print test. There is no reason to suppose that they would have created a whole golden background when they knew that they were going to drop artwork into that spot. The glitches on the Chinese cards are just that, glitches. They are not related to this at all.
 
He sent me a very blurry image of the evo box.
Less than useless. Claims it's the best he can do with his cell phone.
But he sells coins and there are lots of close ups of those.
 
My prediction: The seller claims "each are rarer than charizard". I predict he will just so happen to have one thus, listing it for a large sum..
 
Well considering no ones ever seen, or heard of them before, and only four are known to exist.
I guess they're rarer then Illustrator Pikachus. Why doesn't he just say that?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top