Pokémon TCG: Sword and Shield—Brilliant Stars

Pokemon Catcher, Player Rewards Edition!

DarkStar20

Front Page Editor
displayimage.php

Pokemon Catcher Released as a Player Reward Promo!


Looks like this is the "highly sought after Pokémon Trainer card" that Pokemon was referring to for the top 100 players in each age division for Play Points on the Player Rewards Info Page. That sound right to you guys?
 
Last edited:
Horrible descesion

Players that go to that many events already have catchers and rewarding the players for having more events around them isnt right and is very unfair especially to the players that are or have had pto issues this season
 
Would be MUCH better if these were league promos.

Agreed. Players who receive these will already have catchers, but the people who need them, oh say NEW players won't have them at all. It took me so long to get 3 catchers, but because they are "top 100 in Play! Points" in their division they get them free? Not fair at all.
 
Honestly, this is a bad call. I say this should be a league promo instead. I could see why it is highly sought after, but really? Pokemon Catcher for the Top 100 players in each division? I call a conspiracy. Granted, I do have a playset of Pokemon Catcher (don't ask how) so this really doesn't affect me that much, but this doesn't help players get into the game at all.
 
Horrible descesion

Players that go to that many events already have catchers and rewarding the players for having more events around them isnt right and is very unfair especially to the players that are or have had pto issues this season

yea this is definitely a bad move on their part! yup, these ppl have already invested in these cards and are in the top 100 for a reason. the have the resouces, whatever they may be, to get where they are in that ranking. this is totally unfair.:mad:

Would be MUCH better if these were league promos.

agreed! I don't know why they gave up on physical league promo cards to begin with! they can do physical and online league promos at the same time!:thumb:

Agreed. Players who receive these will already have catchers, but the people who need them, oh say NEW players won't have them at all. It took me so long to get 3 catchers, but because they are "top 100 in Play! Points" in their division they get them free? Not fair at all.

yes, very true. I have bought one and traded ALOT of stuff that I didn't wanna necessarily wanna trade just to get my hands on the 3 or 4 I have! hell, I didn't have any to spare for my daughter's tourney legal deck as a result! so yea, the ppl who get, don't need em and cause they were lucky in their mathups (cuz I would say about 96% of all decks in this format are bout luck), they get rewarded with these catchers:nonono:?! sheesh!

and we all know that the prices of these particular catchers are gunna be at least twice as much as the regular catchers! tcpi screwed ppl over with the tropical beach promo and now its happening all over again with these catchers! well, I guess my rant here is done!!!
 
Good grief guys, is it not possible to not be selfish for once? I don't think this should be the ONLY venue that Catcher is distributed (it could happen that they do League promos this coming cycle), but whining that they made them available to people, even on a limited basis, is a highly cynical way of looking at it.

Look at it this way: that's 600 more Pokemon Catcher in the world. Perhaps those getting them will be disposing of their original extras?
 
Good grief guys, is it not possible to not be selfish for once? I don't think this should be the ONLY venue that Catcher is distributed (it could happen that they do League promos this coming cycle), but whining that they made them available to people, even on a limited basis, is a highly cynical way of looking at it.

Look at it this way: that's 600 more Pokemon Catcher in the world. Perhaps those getting them will be disposing of their original extras?

Its not really being selfish about it. Congrats to those who get them but its not fair to other players who also play the game but dont have the resources to travel to every event. This also does not help people get into the game.

You cant find Emerging Powers anywhere to try and pack catchers. The catcher in Dark Explorers is a secret rare and the top 100 catchers are even more elusive then the other two. Those 600 catchers are going to some of the elite players of the game. It will break the bank to get them from them.

Its selfish to not want catcher to be available to the masses just to maintain some trade of sale value. Making them League promos is the most unselfish thing that can happen. Its like the mind set of keep the rich richer and the poor poorer. Its like TPC does the exact opposite of what we ask them to do. We ask for Top 8 at Battle Roads, the remove it all together. We ask for Pokemon Catcher to be easier to get, reprinted or made into a league promo and they give them to the top 100 players in PP, making them harder to get.

For once would it be a bad idea to listen to the players who put money into the game.
 
I just think it's a really great reward for people that play a lot of Pokemon. Technically it's a reward for players that participate a lot, not those who win all the time. So this doesn't mean FOR SURE that they don't own catchers. It doesn't have anything to do with money or quality investment. It's simply 'who's played in the most events.'

So really they are saying hey thanks for playing a lot, here are two copies of this card that only have 600 in existence. :) I think that's an awesome decision! Essentially this gives players motivation to not just show up at the 'championship points events'. The point could be made that they could release catcher as a more generic promo sure, but that's not really the argument at hand...
 
This also does not help people get into the game.
Didn't realize the point of Player Rewards was to get players into the game. Oh wait, it's to reward the people who play the game.
Its like TPC does the exact opposite of what we ask them to do. We ask for Top 8 at Battle Roads, the remove it all together. We ask for Pokemon Catcher to be easier to get, reprinted or made into a league promo
Top Cut at BR has nothing to do with this—And what makes you say they won't reprint it elsewhere? All they did was add 600 copies to the circulation. This CANNOT be a negative thing. Nowhere did they say they will not be reprinting it elsewhere.

and they give them to the top 100 players in PP, making them harder to get.
Explain to me how releasing 600 more copies of the card makes it harder to acquire?
For once would it be a bad idea to listen to the players who put money into the game.
Ways TPCI has made this game cheaper to play:
-Mewtwo/Darkrai/Rayquaza Tins.
-Upcoming Plasma Tins.
-Juniper, Cheren, and N are all available in multiple sets.
etc.
I'd say that's quite the generalization you've chosen to make. There's been bad decisions, but you absolutely cannot say they haven't been accompanied by good changes.


Anyway, these are Player Rewards. The goal is to reward Players for playing the game. I don't necessarily agree with the Top 100, but it isn't the end of the world. Is it too much to ask for people to accept that they didn't earn them and just get on with their lives?
 
Last edited:
Didn't realize the point of Player Rewards was to get players into the game. Oh wait, it's to reward the people who play the game.

Agreed

Top Cut at BR has nothing to do with this—And what makes you say they won't reprint it elsewhere? All they did was add 600 copies to the circulation. This CANNOT be a negative thing. Nowhere did they say they will not be reprinting it elsewhere.

Reprinting them as league promos is not a negative thing either. It makes them easier to get for everyone else and helps get new player into the game or those who cant afford to drop a large amount of money on the game but still want to support it.

Explain to me how releasing 600 more copies of the card makes it harder to acquire?

The umcommon print of Pokemon Catcher is out of print. The set is not being printed anymore. That makes it hard to get. You can still find Dark Explorers packs if you look hard enough for them but the catcher is that set is harder to get then the uncommon catcher because it in every other third box. This catcher, while its adds 600 to the current catcher are harder to get then the gold catcher because the top 100 in each age group with the most PP will own them, two per player. Those players wont trade those cards. Those catchers are further out of reach to us players then the gold ones. All versions of catcher are hard to get, explain to me how they aren't.

Ways TPCI has made this game cheaper to play:
-Mewtwo/Darkrai/Rayquaza Tins.
-Upcoming Plasma Tins.
-Juniper, Cheren, and N are all available in multiple sets.
etc.
I'd say that's quite the generalization you've chosen to make. There's been bad decisions, but you absolutely cannot say they haven't been accompanied by good changes.

The tin promos are easy to get. Catcher is not. If catcher were a tin promo then it would be easy to get. Most EX cards are more common then Pokemon catcher. In the case of Juniper, cheren, etc. This is like comparing apples to oranges. If Juniper and co were printed in one set, that is no longer in print then a gold SR version was printed of them which is harder to get then the uncommon prints and then the player rewards version of them were given to 100 players in each age group, then you would have a argument because they would be as hard to get as catcher.

The big difference is those cards have many different reprints that are easy to get. You dont have to play with full art supporters to be competitive. You dont have to play with reverse foil cards to be competitive. You can pay 50 cents to 1 dollar and buy junipers you need for your deck. However, to be competitive, you need catchers (subjective), but the lowest print of the card is hard to get.

TPCi has made a few good choices. Releasing Mewtwo EX and other meta EX cards were by far the best move they made. If they are willing to ruin resale values of their own sets to make cards easier to get, then why not reprint catcher, the one card to really impact the format.

Anyway, these are Player Rewards. The goal is to reward Players for playing the game. I don't necessarily agree with the Top 100, but it isn't the end of the world. Is it too much to ask for people to accept that they didn't earn them and just get on with their lives?

I agree with this but is is too much to ask people to just look outside their own situations for once. Again congrats to those who earned them. Perhaps they could have stamped those cards as "top 100 Play Points" and give league leaders the normal league promo catchers just for playing. Everyone win.
 
Basically all the complaints here boil down to

"TCPI gave me one scoop of free ice cream but I want ten free"
 
Are we sure its the reward for the top 100?
The pokemon website says they get 2 copies of a highly sought after Pokémon Trainer card.

The photo looks like there are 3 or 4 copies in the pack.
 
Are we sure its the reward for the top 100?
The pokemon website says they get 2 copies of a highly sought after Pokémon Trainer card.

The photo looks like there are 3 or 4 copies in the pack.

It is confirmed that there are 2 Catcher in each pack.
 
Vaporeon said:
Originally Posted by King Piplup

Didn't realize the point of Player Rewards was to get players into the game. Oh wait, it's to reward the people who play the game.



Agreed
At least we agree on that.
Originally Posted by King Piplup

Top Cut at BR has nothing to do with this—And what makes you say they won't reprint it elsewhere? All they did was add 600 copies to the circulation. This CANNOT be a negative thing. Nowhere did they say they will not be reprinting it elsewhere.



Reprinting them as league promos is not a negative thing either. It makes them easier to get for everyone else and helps get new player into the game or those who cant afford to drop a large amount of money on the game but still want to support it.
Please quote where anyone said making Catcher a league promo was a bad idea.
Originally Posted by King Piplup

Explain to me how releasing 600 more copies of the card makes it harder to acquire?



The umcommon print of Pokemon Catcher is out of print. The set is not being printed anymore. That makes it hard to get. You can still find Dark Explorers packs if you look hard enough for them but the catcher is that set is harder to get then the uncommon catcher because it in every other third box. This catcher, while its adds 600 to the current catcher are harder to get then the gold catcher because the top 100 in each age group with the most PP will own them, two per player. Those players wont trade those cards. Those catchers are further out of reach to us players then the gold ones. All versions of catcher are hard to get, explain to me how they aren't.

600 Catchers in the hands of those that got them can easily mean 600 regular Catcher in the market. It definitely increases the number in existence, which is good.
Originally Posted by King Piplup

Ways TPCI has made this game cheaper to play:

-Mewtwo/Darkrai/Rayquaza Tins.

-Upcoming Plasma Tins.

-Juniper, Cheren, and N are all available in multiple sets.

etc.

I'd say that's quite the generalization you've chosen to make. There's been bad decisions, but you absolutely cannot say they haven't been accompanied by good changes.

The tin promos are easy to get. Catcher is not.
EXACTLY!!! TPCI has made cards that were hard to get easier to get. They absolutely are not obligated to make EVERY card easily available to the masses, we should be grateful with what they have done.
If catcher were a tin promo then it would be easy to get. Most EX cards are more common then Pokemon catcher. In the case of Juniper, cheren, etc. This is like comparing apples to oranges. If Juniper and co were printed in one set, that is no longer in print then a gold SR version was printed of them which is harder to get then the uncommon prints and then the player rewards version of them were given to 100 players in each age group, then you would have a argument because they would be as hard to get as catcher.

-EPO is found in all sorts of box products. The packs are still obtainable.
-Aha, but if Juniper had not been reprinted, it would be even rarer than Catcher! My point is that TPCI made a good choice in making Juniper accessible, and they are not obligated to do so with Catcher.
[/quote]
The big difference is those cards have many different reprints that are easy to get. You dont have to play with full art supporters to be competitive. You dont have to play with reverse foil cards to be competitive. You can pay 50 cents to 1 dollar and buy junipers you need for your deck. However, to be competitive, you need catchers (subjective), but the lowest print of the card is hard to get.
Again, my point is that they HAVE made Juniper more accessible through another print, and that we should realize that 600 more Catcher is a step in the right direction.
I agree with this but is is too much to ask people to just look outside their own situations for once. Again congrats to those who earned them. Perhaps they could have stamped those cards as "top 100 Play Points" and give league leaders the normal league promo catchers just for playing. Everyone win.
You seem to think I have something against it being a league promo. I don't. My point is that whining that they've released 600 more Catchers is silly and makes you look unintelligent.
 
I guess I'll throw my lot in with the "why can't it be a league promo" side. Though to be fair, outside of something even more exclusive like the Tropical Beach Worlds promo, Catcher is pretty much the best promo you can make for top 100 players considering other major metagame cards like Darkrai EX are promos/tins already, and ones like Computer Search are "less valuable" in the grand scheme of things.

This also means we'll be stuck with Catcher for another format likely, kinda meh imo since I'd like to get away from it now that we have Warp Point (er Escape Rope) back now.
 
Back
Top