Sabett
Active Member
So here's the card:
Raichu - Lightning - HP100
Stage 1 - Evolves from Pikachu
Poke-Power: Voltage Up
You can use this power any number of times during your turn. Move 1 Lightning Energy attached to one of your Pokemon to this Pokemon. This Power can't be used if this Pokemon is affected by a Special Condition.
[L][L][C] Mega Thunderbolt: 120 damage. Discard all Energy attached to Raichu.
Weakness: Fighting (x2)
Resistance: Steel (-20)
Retreat: 1
Now I've been liking this card ever since I saw it, (on a casual level of course), but something disturbs me now that I realize something. This won't be in the format with Electivire SW, and if that's happening, then I fail to see the big prime part this raichu has over the GS one. The power loses a lot of utility once electivire is out of the picture. It doesn't even get to keep the energy and toss it on to a new Raichu. The GS Raichu has free retreat, and for 20 less damage and an energy less you essentially get the same attack. There are only a few things I can really stretch in mind for the prime, one is the Pachi from LL. When you lay it down on the bench you get to attach 2 lightning energy to it, and the other is rayquaza C Lv.X. Other than that, I don't see much reason to run the Prime over the GS Raichu, I mean if damage is an issue, you could just run Crobat G, which you should be doing anyway with the Lv.X's attack, and the only time you'd really need it is for like a bronzong G on the bench, which I hardly see anymore, and the extra 10 on the luxray and garchomp Xs. The only thing that really comes to mind that's a big issue on the damage part is donphan prime, with it's body and resistance, it's knocking 40 damage off of raichu's attacks, however with a stadium that more than likely should be in here, Sunyshore City Gym, not only does it combat Raichu's weakness, but also skirts by Donphans resistance. At this point The GS raichu would be doing 80, and the Prime would be doing 100, and if we add an expert belt, 100 and 120, giving raichu an elaborate OHKO against Donphan. So an extensive, but not terrible, OHKO against donphan, and two sub par pokemon to use for acceleration. This doesn't sound so hot for a prime to be literally outclassed in an identical manner design wise.
Also, a bit of a tangent, why does every raichu have to have good attacks that involve discarding energy? I know it's kind of Electric's thing, but the Luxray from AR found a way to not do it, and make a great a attack. Why couldn't a Raichu, a Prime Raichu at that, be given a different attack than one that makes him discard all energy cards attached to him?
EDIT: thank you mods
Raichu - Lightning - HP100
Stage 1 - Evolves from Pikachu
Poke-Power: Voltage Up
You can use this power any number of times during your turn. Move 1 Lightning Energy attached to one of your Pokemon to this Pokemon. This Power can't be used if this Pokemon is affected by a Special Condition.
[L][L][C] Mega Thunderbolt: 120 damage. Discard all Energy attached to Raichu.
Weakness: Fighting (x2)
Resistance: Steel (-20)
Retreat: 1
Now I've been liking this card ever since I saw it, (on a casual level of course), but something disturbs me now that I realize something. This won't be in the format with Electivire SW, and if that's happening, then I fail to see the big prime part this raichu has over the GS one. The power loses a lot of utility once electivire is out of the picture. It doesn't even get to keep the energy and toss it on to a new Raichu. The GS Raichu has free retreat, and for 20 less damage and an energy less you essentially get the same attack. There are only a few things I can really stretch in mind for the prime, one is the Pachi from LL. When you lay it down on the bench you get to attach 2 lightning energy to it, and the other is rayquaza C Lv.X. Other than that, I don't see much reason to run the Prime over the GS Raichu, I mean if damage is an issue, you could just run Crobat G, which you should be doing anyway with the Lv.X's attack, and the only time you'd really need it is for like a bronzong G on the bench, which I hardly see anymore, and the extra 10 on the luxray and garchomp Xs. The only thing that really comes to mind that's a big issue on the damage part is donphan prime, with it's body and resistance, it's knocking 40 damage off of raichu's attacks, however with a stadium that more than likely should be in here, Sunyshore City Gym, not only does it combat Raichu's weakness, but also skirts by Donphans resistance. At this point The GS raichu would be doing 80, and the Prime would be doing 100, and if we add an expert belt, 100 and 120, giving raichu an elaborate OHKO against Donphan. So an extensive, but not terrible, OHKO against donphan, and two sub par pokemon to use for acceleration. This doesn't sound so hot for a prime to be literally outclassed in an identical manner design wise.
Also, a bit of a tangent, why does every raichu have to have good attacks that involve discarding energy? I know it's kind of Electric's thing, but the Luxray from AR found a way to not do it, and make a great a attack. Why couldn't a Raichu, a Prime Raichu at that, be given a different attack than one that makes him discard all energy cards attached to him?
EDIT: thank you mods
Last edited: