Hi there,
Quick question on how to rule in a specific case : a Gengar attacked using Poltergeist having only 1 energy ( Poltergeist needs 2 ) . None of the players realized that at the moment, and the attack then killed the defending pokemon. Once with the pokemon in the discard pile, and the prize card taken, we then realized Gengar could not attack with Poltergeist because of the energy. A few questions about the correct ruling on such situation :
- Should then the defending pokemon get back in play, the prize put back, and Gengar be allowed to attack with Shadow Room ?
- Should the attack be considered as "failed" as Gengar declared an attack that could not be performed due to lack of energy, but the attack happened , and the turn ends ?
- Should the attack proceed as it was finished by both players and the defending pokemon is already on the discard pile, prize remains taken, and then the turn ends with a new defending pokemon being brought to play from the bench ?
Just want to know what's the correct way to rule this. Caused a bit of a heated discussion among players.
Thx in advance.
Quick question on how to rule in a specific case : a Gengar attacked using Poltergeist having only 1 energy ( Poltergeist needs 2 ) . None of the players realized that at the moment, and the attack then killed the defending pokemon. Once with the pokemon in the discard pile, and the prize card taken, we then realized Gengar could not attack with Poltergeist because of the energy. A few questions about the correct ruling on such situation :
- Should then the defending pokemon get back in play, the prize put back, and Gengar be allowed to attack with Shadow Room ?
- Should the attack be considered as "failed" as Gengar declared an attack that could not be performed due to lack of energy, but the attack happened , and the turn ends ?
- Should the attack proceed as it was finished by both players and the defending pokemon is already on the discard pile, prize remains taken, and then the turn ends with a new defending pokemon being brought to play from the bench ?
Just want to know what's the correct way to rule this. Caused a bit of a heated discussion among players.
Thx in advance.