Which of these 2 cards is worth more money?

[hyruleguardian]

PSA 9 1st Edition Base Set Charizard

or

PSA 10 1st Edition Shining Mewtwo?

I was wondering because I was offered this exact trade and I was wondering if I should accept it or not.

Thanks.

 

[Qwachansey]

I would say the 1st Edition Base Charizard.

 

[hyruleguardian]

Any idea of how much the Mewtwo might be worth?

 

[Qwachansey]

Maybe up to $50. I would say the Charizard is $150 - $250.

 

[hyruleguardian]

Thanks for your thoughts. I was fairly certain the Charizard was worth significantly more but I wanted another opinion.

I know it's also hard to estimate because only 3 Shining Mewtwos have even been PSA graded and thus the card has no real sales history.

 

[Qwachansey]

Sure, but even if there was only 1 PSA 10, it wouldn't been the Mewtwo was worth more.

 

[smpratte]

Charizard, I think the mewtwo should be worth $100 in my opinion but psa cards besides the first sets are difficult to sell.

 

[Will-iam]

The Charizard, despite that there are only 2 graded Shinning 1st ed Mewtwos and both of them got 10s. The Charizard comes from a much more popular set. However since you hyruleguardian have now an awesome PSA-10 1st ed Charizard if I read a previous post on another thread correctly the trade IMO wouldn't be that bad, if you are in to collecting cards and not selling them.

 

[TheDarkTwins]

It's no contest, Charizard is worth MUCH more than the Mewtwo.

Drew

 

[hyruleguardian]

Hmmm... I was just offered the same deal and he offered to give me $100 as well.

Is this a more reasonable deal?

 

[Zephyr]

More reasonable, but you can get more pretty easily.

 

[homeofmew]

Charizard. Especially if it is shadowless.