Nick15 said:
[I dunno... I kinda figured the game's designers were out of ideas when they started to make ex Pokemon. Changing their types seems to be equally... uhm.. "out of idea"-ish, basically a gimmic. I've always frowned upon superficial changes to the game like, well, changing their type, and have felt that better cards would sell the set itself.
I have felt that way for a long time. They may as well just name each new set: "EX- we're running low on ideas for new cards."
I think it would be great if they could focus on making sets that change the game and add new strategy without having to invent new "types" of cards like δ Pokemon and Dual-type Pokemon that make no sense. Now, I can see why they came up with Supporters and Pokemon-EX (I don't see that as being the kind of thing that just screams, "OMG we ran out of good ideas! Please accept this strange new game mechanic (ie. δ Pokemon, React Energy) until we can come up with something good."). They wanted to make Pokemon that were super-powerful with a disadvantage that wasn't some restrictive Poke-body. Also, they wanted the game to be less of "Trainermon" and more about Pokemon, so they restricted the amount of good trainers people would use by makeing the really good ones supporters.
Don't get me wrong, I will play Pokemon forever; It's my favorite game. The current Modified metagame appears to be very diverse and PUI is doing a good job keeping it that way. I just think they should keep the game fun and diverse without adding so many strange characteristics to it. If they keep this up too long, we may be seing "Gothic", "Love", and "Radioactive"
cards.
The card "types" are fine the way they are. Having nine colors of Pokemon (Colorless, Water, Fire, Gras, Lightning, Fighting, Psychic, Metal, Dark), five types trainers (Stadium, Supporter, TM, Poketool), and six basic energies is enough. They don't need to add any more. After RS, the game was headed in the right direction, but if we see any more of these superficial changes to the game then I think the game is headed in the wrong direction.
Perhaps they should start getting ideas from the fake card community (I'm sure there are plenty of people on the 'gym alone who could come up with some useful and not too broken card ideas). It would also be nice to add some of the
older cards to Modified with
reprints.