KK- "theme countering" is if an opponant has pokies in a ratio "in favor" as too how the battles are set up by the GL.
One flying in a 4 vs 4 pokie battle against a "ground" theme is acceptable. Two will not be acceptable.
If you allow the use of certain Pokies that are against the standered ground rules, that option is there- as the set standered rules apply if a GL wants to use a "simple" format to host their theme by.
In order of rules and restrictions, a GL should adbide by the standered basic rules if they choose not to have side rules.
In the case of countering and the pokies allowed- this is what I say: The GL has not chosen to follow the basic standered rules, thus Pokies allowed and not allowed are in their personal side rules. The use of "banned" pokies in a battle by a challenger against a GL according to the side rules is what will cause an auto loss to the challenger. The challenger is then in the "cool down" period at that time. The Challenger can battle other GL's who are available in that time frame.
Since this is an event that leaves room for VGC practice, and you GL's have the right to modify your Gym as you see fit without changing your main theme. Side rules you GL's create are also changeable, as it will keep your Gym "fresh" and non-predictable ( pokie choice or a change in your claus ).
"Theme countering" is based on the ratio of challenger pokies. In the case of Salamance and Lugia being used against a ground gym theme in a 4 vs 4 double battle, the flying type ratio breaches that ratio in favor of the challenger. Since in the rematch, Starapture and Lugia were used, thus again in "theme countering status".
I will rule in Favor of the GL at this time, based on the information I have recieved.
@cheeseEx- You can challenge other GL's in the meantime and rematch after two days, please understand what "theme countering" is, if you are not sure the ratio of Pokies in your team should be, ask the GL you are challenging what the ratio is. I am sure the other Gl's will be glad to battle you, and ggod luck and have fun.