King Piplup
Active Member
Ah well, mistakes happen. At this point, I suguest we find a lynch target? Scott (Quiet...) or PM? (Quiet, VI, anyone?)
Werewolf xvi the rise of team plasma: Town wins
- Thread starter Arcanine/Arbok Master
- Start date
mmm.... I am going to need a lot more explanation than that.
Pikamaster
Active Member
If we're going to ignore DragonClyne, I'd want to go for PMysterious. Considering that he's quiet and the one post he did make was drastically better than anything else he's posted. Scott is also a viable option. So either one could easily earn my vote, I have to go and can't post more atm, though.
King Piplup
Active Member
JewelQuest
New Member
Shauntal also uses Cofagrigus, Golurk, and Chandelure. Was the Chandelure in the night one update yours, KP?
Between PM and Scott I say that Scott is still the one that pops out to me the most as 'wolf'. Since he has not posted(the only reason I hadn't voted before was because he said that he would be away, but he hasn't come back) I shall now make my vote.
Vote: Scottistru
PM, though he is acting awful, still reads to me as a VI(though I may be totally wrong about this). If he is a wolf, I don't find him as much of a threat as there is no way that anyone in this thread is going to follow his lead in lynching someone.
Dragonclyne just needs to explain a bit more. I don't really see him as the next lynch target, though.
Between PM and Scott I say that Scott is still the one that pops out to me the most as 'wolf'. Since he has not posted(the only reason I hadn't voted before was because he said that he would be away, but he hasn't come back) I shall now make my vote.
Vote: Scottistru
PM, though he is acting awful, still reads to me as a VI(though I may be totally wrong about this). If he is a wolf, I don't find him as much of a threat as there is no way that anyone in this thread is going to follow his lead in lynching someone.
Dragonclyne just needs to explain a bit more. I don't really see him as the next lynch target, though.
King Piplup
Active Member
As confirmed above, I use Jellicent-Chandy would make more sense though, I agree totally. I wish I had a Chandelure... (My favorite 5GEN is Litwick...)
JewelQuest
New Member
Hmm. :/ Then I wonder where the Chandelure came from? (I believe you BTW...). Maybe a character not from Pokemon has one?
King Piplup
Active Member
OK. Napoleon's role is almost certainty (I have no doubt, but...) a role of a townie. If a wolf had this role it would be useless to them. An indie couldn't make much of it either. It is a townie's role.
That said, I did not see Napoleon's win condition. I am not a full seer, I only get the abilities of a character.
I do! Start:
Unvote: reados1
Vote: DragonClyne725
My reasons are:
-ambiguous self claim
- faulty kp claim
- oops my bad.
PokeChampofPokeBeach
New Member
So these are the people who voted for SS7 last game day.
AbsolTrainer
Diaz
DragonClyne725
PMysterious
Scottistru
Jellyfisher
Son_of_Apollo
PokechampOfPokebeach
Redados1
KingPiplup
Absoltrainer was ruled out of consideration because he was the first to attack SS7. Diaz ruled himself out because he (1.) Suggested the theory that a Werewolf voted for SS7 in the first place, thus he argued it would be unlikely for him to do that if he were the Wolf that voted for him and (2.) He was role-blocked by the wolves in the night update. While neither of these things completely disprove that Diaz could be a wolf, I do find it highly unlikely that he would have brought the theory up in the first place, especially considering he was on the list. I am willing to believe that he is town, however I am interested in hearing others thoughts on this point. Jellyfisher cannot be ruled out entirely, but there is no evidence that he is scum at the moment either, so putting his on the name list with scummy players isn't going to be worth anything. Son_Of_Apollo could be ruled out. He's been bandwagoning the entire game, however he did name-claim a GL and he hasn't been counter-claimed. Due to the proven existence of GLs in this game, I do believe him, despite the fact that his play has been somewhat suspicious. I was ruled out from the list because I name-claimed day 1 and I was found in the night update proving my claim to be true. KP has revealed his character name and his role, he went completely on the line and the only point of incongruity in his claim that I can think of is Prohawk's point about Jellicent. Aside from that small point, I see no reason to disbelieve him. KP vouches for Redados1's innocence and seeing as he is the seer I also do not disbelieve this. Therefore I feel it safe to remove both of their names from the list.
DragonClyne725
PMysterious
Scottistru
Dragonclyne is looking pretty suspicious. He voted for KP based on information he had accrued through his role. He blamed it on a misunderstanding between himself and A/AM. He also has contradicted himself, taking a stand against name-claiming and then revealing himself to be a GL in the same post. According to Dragonclyne, he claims that he did not understand part of his role. He was apparently very sure of what his role did when he voted for KP. I fail to see how a "little birdie" can tell you that someone is not from the Pokemon universe, when they actually are and are also a seer at that, and then in later you realize that you don't understand you role. His claim was against KP was specific enough, I have trouble believing that you gather something completely contrary to a person's character from mis-reading the effect of your role. As it stands, there is no way to vouch the conversation between Dragonclyne and A/AM even took place.
Dragonclyne has blatantly contradicted himself TWICE now. He was willing to reveal that he was a GL, but unwilling to name-claim. He claimed and tried to hammer votes on KP on the false premise that he was "not from the Pokemon universe", when KP is in fact from the Pokemon universe.
Vote: Dragonclyne
You have explaining to do.
AbsolTrainer
Diaz
DragonClyne725
PMysterious
Scottistru
Jellyfisher
Son_of_Apollo
PokechampOfPokebeach
Redados1
KingPiplup
Absoltrainer was ruled out of consideration because he was the first to attack SS7. Diaz ruled himself out because he (1.) Suggested the theory that a Werewolf voted for SS7 in the first place, thus he argued it would be unlikely for him to do that if he were the Wolf that voted for him and (2.) He was role-blocked by the wolves in the night update. While neither of these things completely disprove that Diaz could be a wolf, I do find it highly unlikely that he would have brought the theory up in the first place, especially considering he was on the list. I am willing to believe that he is town, however I am interested in hearing others thoughts on this point. Jellyfisher cannot be ruled out entirely, but there is no evidence that he is scum at the moment either, so putting his on the name list with scummy players isn't going to be worth anything. Son_Of_Apollo could be ruled out. He's been bandwagoning the entire game, however he did name-claim a GL and he hasn't been counter-claimed. Due to the proven existence of GLs in this game, I do believe him, despite the fact that his play has been somewhat suspicious. I was ruled out from the list because I name-claimed day 1 and I was found in the night update proving my claim to be true. KP has revealed his character name and his role, he went completely on the line and the only point of incongruity in his claim that I can think of is Prohawk's point about Jellicent. Aside from that small point, I see no reason to disbelieve him. KP vouches for Redados1's innocence and seeing as he is the seer I also do not disbelieve this. Therefore I feel it safe to remove both of their names from the list.
DragonClyne725
PMysterious
Scottistru
Dragonclyne is looking pretty suspicious. He voted for KP based on information he had accrued through his role. He blamed it on a misunderstanding between himself and A/AM. He also has contradicted himself, taking a stand against name-claiming and then revealing himself to be a GL in the same post. According to Dragonclyne, he claims that he did not understand part of his role. He was apparently very sure of what his role did when he voted for KP. I fail to see how a "little birdie" can tell you that someone is not from the Pokemon universe, when they actually are and are also a seer at that, and then in later you realize that you don't understand you role. His claim was against KP was specific enough, I have trouble believing that you gather something completely contrary to a person's character from mis-reading the effect of your role. As it stands, there is no way to vouch the conversation between Dragonclyne and A/AM even took place.
Dragonclyne has blatantly contradicted himself TWICE now. He was willing to reveal that he was a GL, but unwilling to name-claim. He claimed and tried to hammer votes on KP on the false premise that he was "not from the Pokemon universe", when KP is in fact from the Pokemon universe.
Vote: Dragonclyne
You have explaining to do.
Sandslash7
<a href="http://pokegym.net/forums/showpost.php?p=
Dead Guy Bump Inc at your service.
Diaz
New Member
Great post. I just don't feel comfortable dropping Jellyfisher yet.
PokeChampofPokeBeach
New Member
Well, Jellyfisher cannot be dropped from the list entirely, on that I agree. But there also no valid grounds to justify persecuting him. A case cannot currently be made against him, whereas you CAN make a case for any of the three people I have just mentioned. That is the only reason I removed him from the list. I am in no way saying that is an impossibility that Jellyfisher could be a Werewolf. There is no evidence either way.
King Piplup
Active Member
(Thankfully) Alive Bump LLC at your service
Posted with Mobile style...
Posted with Mobile style...
DragonClyne725
New Member
Shauntal's Cofagrigus, Drifblim, Chandelure, and Froslass all have Psychic, so that may have something to do with it. However, I 100% believe that KP is telling the truth, and that I was a complete idiot to call him out like that. :nonono:
Pikamaster said:
Thanks, that sure makes me feel better about my mistake.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
We need to focus on finding our lynch target. I believe that Redados1 is Town (explained below). I think that either PMysterious or Scottistru is a good choice. Both have been silent (Scottistru said he'd be able to get on tonight to vote) and seem scummish to me. IF EITHER OF YOU TWO ARE READING THIS, POST SOMETHING AS TO WHY WE SHOULDN'T LYNCH YOU.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Might as well throw my cards in. I am Brycen of the Icirrus Gym. It's pretty chill, being an Ice trainer and all, but the cool part of it is that I picked up the PokeBall dropped in the Begin Night 3 Update. It contained a Woobat (code name: little birdie). I can use it to follow someone around and get any information it finds. I targeted KP, and I received the information that KP received during the Night. I mistook the information I had received for information about KP himself. Therefore, when KP claimed Shauntal, I believed him to be lying from the information I had received (AKA, Redados1's role).
@Redados1: If you wish to verify from your role, 12 words after "Role:" (not counting "Role:") is the word "player".
Diaz
New Member
IMO remove players when you have a reason, not when you don't have reason not to. That's what happened to other players removed from list.
Pikamaster
Active Member
As much as I hate to admit it, DragonClyne has a valid excuse... unless someone else claims he has the Woobat.