Pokémon TCG: Sword and Shield—Brilliant Stars

What's Wrong with this Format?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Clay doesn't need to win anything.

He RUNS everything. He's the PTO for West Tennessee (and area). He's been the Head Judge at Regionals and Worlds LCQ. His credentials speak for themselves.

His daughter wins everything. (check his sig if you don't believe me)
 
and that's why you (djjoe and clay) have never won aything bigger then a cc.

i mean, do you even know what you are talking about?

i like to say i just cp'd my decklist from ht or 6p just to screw with clowns like you.

netdecking isn't bad or unethical. it's part of the game.

200 dollar tropical beaches are also part of the game.

if you don't like it, quit.
Posted with Mobile style...

More like $100 tropical beaches. $200 is far too much for it. . .
 
Clay doesn't need to win anything.

He RUNS everything. He's the PTO for West Tennessee (and area). He's been the Head Judge at Regionals and Worlds LCQ. His credentials speak for themselves.

His daughter wins everything. (check his sig if you don't believe me)

you think i can't read? it only further proves my point.

beach is like 130 now. in a month it'll be 200
Posted with Mobile style...
 
Lol, at least Beach isn't a card u need 3-4 of in a deck. That would be a b-word to get.

But, seriously, card games are expensive if you want to be competitive. This is common knowledge. If you don't like it, then go and buy an xbox and some video games. Oh wait . . .

Point being, entertainment and things that provide pleasure aren't cheap.
 
and that's why you (djjoe and clay) have never won aything bigger then a cc.

i mean, do you even know what you are talking about?

i like to say i just cp'd my decklist from ht or 6p just to screw with clowns like you.

netdecking isn't bad or unethical. it's part of the game.

200 dollar tropical beaches are also part of the game.

if you don't like it, quit.
Posted with Mobile style...

Because pointing out what I haven't won nor even bothered to participate in helps or proves any point?

Of course I know what I'm talking about, I sit down and think before I try and speak or type my opinion.

You like to say and do stupid things, others don't. If that's what floats your boat, more power to you. Just don't expect a heck of a lot of respect because of it.

Netdecking is not part of the game. It's a resource of people. A part of the game is drawing a card. Purchasing or otherwise obtaining cards. Playing Pokemon. Playing Trainers. Those are part of the game. Netdecking, if it never existed, would not have a direct impact on the game.

200 Dollar Tropical Beaches are not part of the game. Not yet. They're not there yet, so stop saying they are. If you want to let yours (assuming you even have any) collect dust for a few weeks with that pricetag, be my guest.


Psychup: I'm just voicing my opinion, that's all. No defenses, just opinions on a topic. I just have a lot to say here, and I get better prompting to start opinions than I do blindly making topics.
 
Whoa, whoa, whoa. People are actually defending the exclusivity of Tropical Beach? I thought it was generally agreed upon that Tropical Beach's release was a bad thing. How in the world could you think ~100 cards are a good thing for the game? There's nothing good about huge pricetags on good cards, ever. That just turns your game into Yu-Gi-Oh; a game where winning means you have deep pockets, not skill.

We aren't even close to that, but my point stands. That's not a direction I want our game to go.
 
Gas is $4 a gallon in NYC right now. I guess I should've also had the foresight to horde gas when it was still $2 a gallon 15 years ago. How about a house? I guess I also should've had the foresight to buy a house 10 years ago when real estate prices nearly half of what they are now.

You really are taking the logic here and over extending it. It is kind of like if I start jogging regularly, and my time for a mile goes down by a minute after two weeks, I don't assume it will continue to drop every two weeks by a minute so long as I keep training, since eventually I'd be jogging at light speed.

Second the increase in the price of fuel as well as the real estate prices are a huge, complex discussion, full of both private individuals, corporations, and government meddling and incompetence. I won't get into the messy details hear because that isn't the point.

While I don't necessarily agree with the perceived attitude of the posts pointing out that smart players learn to think ahead and buy cards before they get expensive, it is a valid point for any non-new player. I can think of only a few, sad individuals that can legitimately claim they are surprised by these developments and unable to procure the help they need to reasonably speculate, and frankly those who are so strapped for cash that they can't afford over the course of the previous season to buy and/or trade for currently "meh" cards that show promise next season hopefully aren't going to be focusing on running the most expensive deck in the format anyway.

For the record, my budget is and has been shot for quite some time. I've got none of the "good" cards right now. As such I don't expect to have a good deck unless my financial situation radically improved. So I am speaking from past experience: if you aren't the player who can reasonably anticipate what is going to be good, find the websites or friends who will help you, and budget about $50 (whether cash or in trades) to securing the probable future power cards. It seemed pretty clear that the Primes were going to at least adequate for this format, so any player worth his or her salt should have been obtaining as many as they could.

Given the rarity, when they were about $5 a pop you shouldn't have had a terrible time selling/trading them away for at least $2 of stuff had a Prime ended up being bad. If not now, wait a year or two for the supply to dwindle. Cards mostly valued for collecting tend to go up in value, barring things like the fad phase and its price collapse early in the life of the TCG. It isn't that hard to safely store cards, and I've been surprised when some random rare or reverse holo finally found a buyer/trader looking for it, and gotten a decent return for it. You just might have to wait a few years is all.:lol:
 
The main problem isn't in the format, it's in the cards themselves. There are very few search cards, making it much more difficult to tech against bad matchups. There are also many decks, so you can't tech vs them all. That's what's wrong with this format.
 
you think i can't read? it only further proves my point.

beach is like 130 now. in a month it'll be 200
Posted with Mobile style...

I apologize for my earlier tone....sometimes I should erase and rewrite to tone down my response...bad idea writing during planning period at school

Net decking has always been a good strategy..don't get me wrong...its done in every game.

Most people don't want to take a risk playing something that has not been tested as being reliable in a tourney environement.

75% of the decks my daughter plays are rogue...I come up with the general idea...she fixes it. She also wins more than she loses in tournaments.

But the argument about card prices is silly...we make the prices as sellers and we pay them as buyers. If no one is buying then the price will come down. PUI has no care at all for the price of cards on the secondary market...but they do want a balanced tournament scene...there is currently no empirical evidence that the format is in need of fixing.

...by the way...new rogue deck is ready for regionals...like all the decks in the format, it has its positive and negative match-ups...but it is fun
 
Last edited:
This format is trash. ZPS is BS and it's only getting better.

I'll return when skill becomes the biggest factor in Pokemon again.
 
ZPS and first turn rules are the only bad things about the format... Sadly they are very bad things
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top