Pokémon TCG: Sword and Shield—Brilliant Stars

proper pokemon tcg etiquette

If you ever judged a tournament, you would know that there's nothing more annoying than a list that's written in 3 mins and where you can't decipher anything. I saw lists that are not ordered by Pokémon, trainers, and energy, where some cards are crossed out and other written in unreadable small letters between the lines - and that, even from good players who are playing successfully for years.

The most ironical thing is, it takes less time and effort to put it into the decklist program which adds sets and numbers almost automatically. But still, there are players who come up with unreadable and incorrect lists.

If you can consistantly write a legal and readable list within 5 minutes (in a load pre-tournament-enviroment) - ok, but most of the players can't.

I have judged a few tournaments and have done multiple deck checks before as well. I have seen some wacky stuff but, that's what deck checks are for right? I just think it shouldn't be put on the list lol.

Perhaps I am a "special" player who can run through a deck list before a tournament without any mistakes lol
 
Pro Tip
Gentlemen have firm hand shakes. Nobody likes to shake hands with a limp fish. Grasp your opponent's hand firmly, squeeze gently and shake. If you have trouble with shaking hands, check out this helpful website on how to shake hands like a gentleman! http://www.ehow.com/how_2737_shake-hands.html Think of the pre-game set up like a job interview. Be professional, be considerate, and try to be positive.
...So many people (specifically seniors) need to learn this. I have had people reach out to shake, and when they shake, they do just that. Shake their hand without even touching mine. If you don't even try to shake hands the right way ( by that I mean with any emotion at all), don't do it at all. Its just offensive.
 
Great post guy.

Your: "Sometimes it's even a good idea to apologize if you donked them.", hit it on the head for one of my pet peeves.

I just hate it when a player really thinks, because they donk'd me, its "A Good Game". If just winning is your classification of game, its not mine. A "Good" game is about 2 solid decks, 2 solid players trying to out maneuver one another, while besting luck turn after turn.

Another great example "Do not gloat or complain about the match!".

IMO, talking about the game, even if emotionally talking, is different then complaining.
I think not many can separate the two.
Any comment with" if one more turn", is complaint IMO. It is a turn based game, everyone wants one more turn.
But commenting on bad whiffs/top decks or out lucked, yes it is part of the game, but IMO should stir up a response from the opponent on the acknowledgement that that situation would have brought a different light to the game. Again, conversing on aspects of a "good game" Vs. Blind Luck for the Win.
 
Pro Tip
If you played against a newer player to the TCG, it's a great idea to give them helpful tips on the game

I actually find this is an especially good thing to do when you beat an experienced player in a close match. "I don't think you're playing that deck right" or "Who'd you copy that from?" will always elicit a good response.

And a sincere "Hang in there and you'll get good at this game someday" is always appreciated! LOL
 
I'm not 100% certain, but I faintly recall that it says somewhere in the rules documents that cards must be turned a full 90 degrees or 180 degrees for Sleep/Paralyzed and Confusion, respectively. I haven't read the new rules yet, so that might have changed, if was ever a rule at all.

Otherwise, wonderful article! Great job (and good call on bypassing the front page :wink:).
 
Great article! So many things here hit home for me. The smelliness... well yeah. But I think the thing I hate the most about playing against others is when they don't acknowledge your win, citing things like "my hand was bad", or "my cards were prized", or even that they were distracted and didn't play to their full capacity. Don't dismiss your opponent's victory, if they won, give them the cred. I got lucky at nats a few times with donks, and I appologized PROFUSELY every time, it is a part of the game of course, but everyone knows how unjust it feels to lose before you've even gotten a chance to play! I think some sympathy for your opponent and not pretending like you trampled them on skill alone goes a long way in these instances.

Trying to be a good sport for your opponent when the game is going well is important, but I think it's maybe even more crucial to remember these things when on the receiving end of a meltdown or hissyfit from your opponent. People get emotional sometimes, and are embarassed and regretful afterwards. Rubbing it in their face makes it a million times worse, and is probably the most unsportsmanly thing I can think of.

Again, excellent article, and I fully agree about the "tapping" of powers, it's beyond annoying when your opponent uses a power at the start of their turn, does a hundred other things, and goes "uhh I didn't use this power yet, right?"
 
As far as powers go: Tapping is nice but can create a confusing board. We've been using the little energy symbol dice that came with rumble for a while now. Back when Claydol was legal in standard we would put the F symbol on him, and nowadays we use the P symbol for Uxie's Trade Off, etc. helps a bunch.

Big ups on the article, michael.
 
*I'm not posting this in article submission because it takes a week for pokegym to review it. My sideboards article has been posted for 4 days, not even a response yet. So, yeah.





1. Proper Hygiene.
(Take a shower, put on deodorant, brush your teeth, wear clean clothes) Unfortunately all trading card games, tabletop games, and pretty much any event that can take place in a comic book store attracts some smelly people. The last thing anyone wants is to play against someone with bad breath or sit next to a stinky person. There is absolutely no excuse to be out in public and not be clean and fresh. In my opinion, I don't care if you are rude to me because that's apart of going out in public, but if you stink, I'll absolutely never want to talk to you again.

2. Bring all of the necessary tools to play Pokemon.
You need at least your deck, dice, and poison/burn markers. It would really help the pace of the tournament if you also bring a deck sheet so you can hop in line for deck checks right away. Unfortunately, it isn't mandatory to bring one with you, yet. But it's 2010 and everyone should own a computer or have access to a library with one. It isn't that complicated or expensive to print out a deck sheet. If I was in charge of TPCI or whatever, I would make it mandatory. That way when you sign up for the tournament you can do a deck check, it could cut down on a lot of time. Pokegym's deck builder is a great resource, you don't even need to look up a card's set or number as long as you know what it looks like! http://pokegym.net/decklist/pokemon.htm If you don't have a way to print one out, pen and paper!

3. Bring a good attitude.
Wake up, eat some breakfast, and try to be in a good mood. Pokemon tournaments are a social environment and nobody likes a rude person. A lot of what makes Pokemon great is by making friends it can benefit you later down the road. You can have friends who will trade with you and let you borrow cards, you have friends to playtest against, and you can even talk about decks with these people! Always try to be nice and considerate. You never know if you'll need help later and it's always a good thing to help others!


1. Introduce yourself, shake hands, wish your opponent good luck.
No, you don't have to actually wish your opponent good luck, just say it because it's good sportsmanship. Don't be rude when you introduce yourself either. I remember many years ago, when I was much younger and naive, a guy sat down across from me and said, "My name is - and I'm going to wipe the floor with you." Immediately I was put off and snapped back, but even today I can't stand this guy. I'm mostly holding a grudge against him because he ended up donking me and I had a great hand, haha! Most importantly, just don't be rude

2. Don't groan at your hand or reveal it to your neighbor to show off.
This is perfectly acceptable behavior for league games or pickup games with friends, but at a tournament, it's serious business. Always be professional and try to be neutral. What if your opponent has a better hand? You'll just look like an idiot for showing off. What if your terrible hand changes right away and you topdeck a great card? That's even worse because nobody wants their opponent to tell them their hand is bad, get excited, and then see their opponent top deck into oblivion.

3. Proper shuffling.
There are many, many ways to shuffle your deck. Almost any of them are correct besides ones that break the rules. You can not shuffle your deck with your cards face up towards you. They need to be face down to the table so neither you or your opponent can see what cards are on bottom during the shuffling and after your opponent cuts. It's completely understandable if you can't bridge shuffle like dealer's at poker tables. Just please don't lay all your cards on the table and "domino shuffle"! "Pile shuffling" is also a great way to randomize your deck. To do this, hold your deck in one hand and place the top card in it's own pile until you make 3-10 stacks (your preference) then after you've made a specific amount of stacks, start back at the first one and continue until you have no cards left in your deck. Then pick them all up!

Pro Tip
Gentlemen have firm hand shakes. Nobody likes to shake hands with a limp fish. Grasp your opponent's hand firmly, squeeze gently and shake. If you have trouble with shaking hands, check out this helpful website on how to shake hands like a gentleman! http://www.ehow.com/how_2737_shake-hands.html Think of the pre-game set up like a job interview. Be professional, be considerate, and try to be positive.

During your match
So, you've finally started playing against your opponent! But what else do you need to know to have good TCG etiquette? Certainly you aren't finished being a gentlemen!

1. Keep your field neat and tidy!
One of my pet peeves is when my opponent's field is a mess. It makes it harder to see what cards are where, who has tools, how much energy, and what their evolutions are. Always remember that you AND your opponent has to know everything on the field at all times! If it gets to be too much of a problem, your opponent can even call a judge over!

2. Respect the clock!
Playing too fast or too slow can be disorienting to players. Newer players can't keep up with a fast pace, so always recognize this. Older, veteran players cringe when they face someone who moves at a slug's pace. Usually, they won't mind new TCG players taking their time, but if two veterans are playing each other, you better bet if one plays too slowly, a judge will be called.

3. Say what cards you are playing, what you are doing, and say it clearly!
This actually isn't an option, it's a rule. But people sometimes still don't say what they are doing at all times and sometimes mumble or speak softly. Don't be shy! Speak up and always say what you are doing! When it isn't your turn, pay attention to what your opponent is doing in case they play a card improperly or do something they can't (like play a trainer with Spiritomb active). It is the responsibility of both players to pay attention to the state of the game. Don't look at your neighbor's game or anything like that! Stay focused!

4. Be respectful to your opponent and THEIR turn!
Absolutely do not talk or "chat" when it is your opponents turn. This is my biggest pet peeve and I have no patience for this. I'll warn you once and call a judge almost instantly if you do it again, if I have to. Unfortunately, I have had to call a judge over once. The only time you should talk during your opponent's turn is if you have a question or need to power spray or something like that. It's also okay to remind them when they do something wrong like play a trainer with Spiritomb, just politely remind them they can't do that. Also pay attention when it is your opponent's turn!

5. Always offer your opponent to cut your deck.
Every time you shuffle your deck, hold it out to your opponent and ask them if they would like to cut. Don't tell them to cut it, don't cut it for them, or anything like that. Just politely ask if they want to. If they don't, promptly put your deck back down and continue with your turn.

6. Think of everything 50/50!!!
What I mean by 50/50 is when in a tournament match, you AND your opponent is playing. So when your opponent asks to look at your discard, you should pick up your discard pile and hold it over the field, 50% of the way to give it to them. They will then go the other 50% of the distance to get the discard pile. I know this is silly, but it can be infuriating when you ask to do something and you have to reach across the table because your opponent is inconsiderate. When you shuffle your deck and offer your opponent to cut, hold it out 50% of the way!

7. Don't do anything until your opponent has declared what they are doing.
This includes getting dice ready for damage before they announce what attack and how much it does, drawing for your turn while your opponent is still shuffling, or power spraying when your opponent drops Uxie before they say Set Up. Not only are some of these things against the rules and a judge can be called over, it is certainly inappropriate and rude.


1. Do not gloat or complain about the match!
This seems like common sense to some people but there is always a "that guy" in every pokemon community. At the end of the match, if you lost, don't come up with an excuse just because. Even if there is a pretty clear excuse that you whiffed on the energy or something was prized, you don't have to announce it and diminish your opponent's playing. If you win, absolutely do not gloat about it. This is the worst thing you can do in a pokemon match and you will certainly have no friends if you do it at a tournament!

2. Shake hands and tell your opponent good job.
Even if you won, don't be snarky about it. Remember, the person you beat probably invested a lot of time in their deck and wanted to win just as bad as you did! Be respectful and tell them they did a good job regardless of the outcome. Sometimes it's even a good idea to apologize if you donked them. Hopefully they will understand that is apart of the game of pokemon and happens to everyone.


thoses are defentily the most important parts this needs to be front page article asap
 
Sometimes, the best articles don't set out on the "article" status, so much as just communicating a good message to friends and others. This is one of those.

The only thing that could've been added to make this an even better read would be something on how to deal with BAD etiquette. It's important to know the difference between standing up for yourself and just being a jerk in response to a jerk...Which does nobody good. Sometimes that line is drawn in a gray area, but it's always there.
 
Should be included: I HATE, HATE, HATE when people declare their attack and put damage counters on MY pokemon....that's my job. It's even worse when they put MY damage counters on MY card. Don't touch my stuff without asking, period.
 
Also tying into what I said earlier, we should show the _utmost_ respect for people who realize that they DID make a mistake, and own up to it.

For me, a simple "sorry" goes such a long way, and I can usually tell that this person is a class act.
 

2. Respect the clock!
Playing too fast or too slow can be disorienting to players. Newer players can't keep up with a fast pace, so always recognize this. Older, veteran players cringe when they face someone who moves at a slug's pace. Usually, they won't mind new TCG players taking their time, but if two veterans are playing each other, you better bet if one plays too slowly, a judge will be called.


I couldn't disagree more. Some of the best players in the game play naturally slowly. They don't stall, they just take time to think and make sure they aren't mking mistakes. I was watching Sami Sekkuoum vs. Yuda Komatsuda's Top 8 game at worlds - two of the best players in the world, and they were playing really slowly. Not stalling, just taking time to think. It's unreasonable to expect the average player to play fast if they want to think when the best in the game take their time. That's not saying you shouldn't be vigilant about stalling, that's a different thing. And yes, there is a stage where people cvan take too long but for the most part if there's no possible incentive to stall the player playing slowly is just deliberating over their strategy.

This is a competetive game, there's no reason to feel you should speed up just to keep your opponent from being bored.

I do really like the article though.
 
Last edited:
As far as powers go: Tapping is nice but can create a confusing board. We've been using the little energy symbol dice that came with rumble for a while now. Back when Claydol was legal in standard we would put the F symbol on him, and nowadays we use the P symbol for Uxie's Trade Off, etc. helps a bunch.

Big ups on the article, michael.

There is someone who was using a marker of some kind to indicate that Claydol's power had been used. I want to say that it was a small Claydol figure that they would put on a Claydol to indicate that the power had already been used.

Does anybody else remember that? There was even a link to a pic of it.
 
I actually find this is an especially good thing to do when you beat an experienced player in a close match. "I don't think you're playing that deck right" or "Who'd you copy that from?" will always elicit a good response.

And a sincere "Hang in there and you'll get good at this game someday" is always appreciated! LOL

I think my sarcasm detector just exploded.
 
Will you guys stop telling people to shower, we're in america for gosh sakes. If someone wants to be stinky, thats great.

Stay Stinky My Friends.
 
Will you guys stop telling people to shower, we're in america for gosh sakes. If someone wants to be stinky, thats great.

Stay Stinky My Friends.


Yep, but eve in America your rights only go so far as to not infringe on someone else's rights. You want to stink- stay home! You want to play- clean up and come on! You don't have the right to force me to breathe your polluted air.
 
Will you guys stop telling people to shower, we're in america for gosh sakes. If someone wants to be stinky, thats great.

Stay Stinky My Friends.

An eye for an eye makes the world go blind; a stink for a stink makes our noses sink.
 
Back
Top