Kayle
Active Member
Based off of what is said in the rules, yes it is our goal. Whether or not we decide to change that, it is our first priority to try to find a solution that does not interfere with the original goal.
Fair, but...
The second option is certainly not ideal. Although it may reduce the amount of garbage it also reduces participation, which is something that we do not want to discourage. Idealy, we should avoid presenting such and option, which leads into the next bit.
This is somewhat contradictory. If you want to promote meaningful, useful, relevant discussion, then by extension you want to DISCOURAGE poorly-thought out and illegitimate discussion - and, by extension, you want to discourage members who consistently offer only advice. IDEALLY they will learn, instead of simply leaving, but things cannot always be ideal.
This is the attitude of pretty much everywhere else I have ever been.
This would help encourage the ideal option (the first one) without interefering with the original goal. I strongly support this, or at least some other form of restriction.
I like it too, but it still has the potential to drive away new members that are easily aggravated by the restriction.
Which brings us back to "the mods are to harsh" problem. As R_A said the friendly reminders are friendly reminders not infractions. Though, I do see how this could get out of hand. Establishing a Guru Points system would be the ideal alternative since it would encourage good posts instead of discouraging bad ones.
I think it's worth pointing out that there are many, many people out there who don't really care at all about an infraction. To them, a warning and an infraction are basically the same thing: they did something and someone came out and told them not to do it. If it's something you felt is minor enough to only warrant a warning... they probably felt it was too minor to matter at ALL, and are going to be pretty miffed that they got an official YOU HAVE BEEN WARNED notification.
It doesn't help that the terminology for some other popular forum hosts does not include "infraction"; instead, punishments are handed out with... "warnings", which actually do accumulate in value and can lead to banning.
We should make official ones, then sticky them.
they are stickied. ;P