Pokémon TCG: Sword and Shield—Brilliant Stars

2007-2008 Modified Format Announced! Major Changes!

No matter how much we might hate this, it is probably the right way to go. I hate this, because I just 2 months ago, just got my transcievers finally. Really, pretty much the only way that u can win is with the holon engine, which is incredible hard for newer players to obtain. I'm sure almost all of us hate it now, but eventually, and hopefully, there will be a new engine... Scottaway is not that engine tho.

Just pray for a Delta Species Returns Set with DP deltas and Holon Engine
 
Some people lead, some people follow.

I won a regional without using a single holon supporter in my deck. And I probably own 20+ Holon Transcievers. .....and yes, I own about 20+ Castaways.

And don't worry folks the word is that they are reprinting ROCKET ADMIN...and Sandstorm Dunsparce.
 
[R]Visitor;861845 said:
Because Pokemon Organized Greed, or whatever they prefer to call themselves, are in charge here in America, and in America, big buisness = screwing over your consumers.

We're taking the bullet here so they can make a quicker buck, it's simple. I was curious why the soon-to-be legal sets were becoming more expensive, while older sets, like Delta Species, stayed the same price. POP is basically going to force you to buy new cards and at a higher price. This is why the announcement was so sudden, to make sure that the average consumer panics and buys up lots of packs at jacked up prices before thinking things through.

The rules of this game should be the same everywhere, but they're not. You think it's bad here? Try Europe. I hear things are quite a cesspool over there when it comes to how well the players are treated. This is a huge step backward from where we were, and POG/POP is turning this game into another magic.

Make up all the excuses you want, Holon Engine this and that, it's all pish posh. Most of the new DP enabled decks MURDER the holon engine. Electanite was going to completely nullify decks like Raieggs.

This is just greed at it's most predictable and understandable level. That's ALL this is folks, is greed. I'll be seeing the rest of you on ebay, selling those cards we all bought like, 3 months ago, which are suddenly illegal already.

Personally, i'd laugh in the face of the guys at PUI/POP/etc. I could run their shady buisness better than they could, in a flash, doesn't take much more than a degree in marketing. :nonono: Shameful buisness is shameful buisness.

This announcement, from what I understand, isn't too far off from when they made the set rotation announcement last year. Just from personal observation, I honestly don't think that POP is acting out from greed. Let's consider the new player to the game for just a second. This player decided just today that he wants to play the Pokemon TCG. His name is Derrick Pants, heh.

Derrick Pants goes to a Battle Roads with his awesome Wildfire Moltres deck. When he gets there, he realizes that his cards are illegal for the tournament, so he hangs around to see what people are playing and takes notes on what he needs to get. After watching some of the games from the topcut, he realizes that the Holon Engine is a must. He also sees a few interesting decks including Mew ex, Banette ex, DS Metagross, and some Diamond & Pearl cards. He talks to a friend who makes the comment that "Flariados would probably beat them all." He checks out some unbelievably good shining Pokemon that he happens to like (Latios*, Latias*, Rayquaza*, and Mew*). He leaves the tournament, hopeful that he can get those cards to play in next week's tournament.

Derrick Pants comes back next week with a very sub-par DS Eeveelutions deck, not the Bandoom, Destiny, Mewtric, Flariados, MetaNite, or Metalix deck he wanted to build. In fact, it will take Derrick a long time to ever acquire those Holon Transceivers, Mew ex's, Banette ex's, etc. that he needs for a tournament-winning deck. Thinking that he would get something good from packs he bought at a nearby store, he only got some random Eeveelutions and a single Armaldo ex. He was happy to pull one Holon Transceiver, but he quickly realized that it wouldn't be enough. After looking on card-selling websites online, he doesn't really feel like buying a Mew ex for $45, and he can't even find Holon Transceivers to buy until he goes to Ebay, where they sell for about $11 each. He mutters under his breath, "For an uncmmon???"

This, however, isn't the worst of it. The worst part occurs at the tournament that Derrick's been so excited about. He truly feels that he's made the best deck he can with his limited resources, so when he sits down to play his first opponent, he doesn't even know what happened until his opponent is circling "win" on the match-slip. Derrick's opponent went first, and he had a Holon Castform active and benched a Pikachu. Derrick got a good start with the "Energy Evolution" Eevee and proceeded to evolve to Flareon and pull his one Holon Energy FF out of his deck. His opponent played a Holon Transceiver, got a Holon Mentor, benched three delta basics, and drew four cards. Derrick knocked out the Castform, and then got knocked out with a Raichu with a Scramble Energy (both being cards his opponent drew from Delta Draw).

The rest of the tournament isn't much fun for Derrick. He can't believe that MetaNite sets up so fast, that Raieggs sets up so fast, that Flygon sets up so fast, etc. etc. etc. He thought he had a decent list, but soon realizes that without the Holon Engine, he's lost the game before he even sits down.

Things get worse when he tries to trade for the Holon Engine. Nobody seems to have any Transceivers for trade, and it's only when he pulls out his Armaldo ex that people are willing to give them up. Derrick doesn't want to give up his only ex at this point! What's worse, he can't get hold of any of the ex's he saw the week before. Choosing to build MetaNite as a last resort, he finds out that a "good list" uses "techs" that he can't find anywhere (Lugia ex, Latios*, Groudon ex, Mew*, Mew ex, etc.* ex).

The story for Derrick Pants is kind of hopeless at this point. Not only is he unable to get certain cards for a deck he'd like to build, he's put at an extreme disadvantage because he can't get the components he needs for the Holon Engine, one of the most used and abused set of cards this game has ever had.

Thing is, to those people who have been saying, "I just finally finally FINALLY got my 4 Transceivers," I do feel sorry for you. But consider the other people who are in your shoes at this point right now. They have a journey ahead of them in getting playable cards, and until they do they probably will not win a tournament. Though things seem frustrating to you, consider those people who are like you were months ago. This decision will make things so much easier on them.

Thank God for this decision. Seriously. I completely agree with Mike. Transceiver and the Holon Engine had such a large stranglehold on this game. I love how all the current archetypes are either gone or severely crippled. This decision will force those who cannot think creatively and not simply metagame/rip decks from the Internet (at least for a time).

This game was for awhile more about luck and matchups and less and less and less and less about skill. That type of game is not fun. For everyone freaking out, there's going to be new cards, have you looked at the DP2 Spoilers? There's some pretty good cards in that set.

I wanted to personally thank POP/PUI for this marvelous decision and making the game fun again. The game isn't so bad when you have to deal with broken Pokemon, those you can counter. But when you have a broken Trainer Engine and have to play your Trainers a certain way, every time AND cut out non-Delta Pokemon, that's when you have a problem.

Looks like I'll be starting this game back up in the Fall after all,

~Jim

YES YES YES!!! Oh man, this is the best. Jim, I actually told my brother last night that next year's format looks like it will be a bit more "Jim-ified." Little did I know...

Let me be the first to welcome you back. :smile: x 50 bajillion.
 
I *am* for all intents Derrick Pants. Sure I didn't have trainers worth a darn at my first Cities ... heck I was lucky to have strong pokemon lines at that point, but my Megainium d / Blastoise deck DID win one game thanks largely to the various deckbuilding guides online. Keep in mind that I bought my first card EVER on November 28th and went to my first City around the second week of December.

I had my first fully working Holon Engine with 4 Trannies by January and a second by Febuary. I held off on getting more since I had a feeling that DS would get rotated.

I take STRONG issue with the idea that cutting sets makes it "easier" on the new guy. If anything it's the reverse. He's unlikely to know which sets are legal at first and tightly resticting sets actually makes it much harder for him to figure out what to buy. There is a TON of old stuff at Target & Walmart now + on eBay the old stuff floats around like crazy.

It's not hard at all to get the cards for 1 playable deck if a newbie actually takes the time to read. Some decks are more expensive than others, so $$ will impact what he ends up with, but there are affordable decks out there. Delta is not bad. Metanite is more expensive, but does not require every single expensive tech to be a reasonable play. There are plenty of rogue decks that may not be top tier but are fine to start with while working on getting the cards for the decks you really want.
 
I totally understand the Holon Engine needing to be rotated out, but Legend Maker? We didn't even get two full seasons use out of those cards.

I also don't entirely feel the Holon Engine stifled creativity. At least not for the players who are ACTUALLY creative and don't just pull a list off the internet.

All I can say is I hope Castaway gets reprinted, and soon.
 
And people thought I was stupid for buying three boxes of CG.

Thank you POP. The Engine was this season's Pidgeot.

.....of course, most decks are gonna run CastaScott and /or Catty now. lol

Edit: WE WANT LEGEND MAKER!
 
First of all, I just read this whole topic, and I don't really know what to say. I feel bad for any one who is really mad about their cards getting rotated. I really hope nobody quits because of this. Personally, I'm torn. I have put a LOT of money into a flygon deck, and that's probably dead. But I CANNOT WAIT to start building a deck that will fit the next format. Everyone's gonna be goin crazy trying to figure out what the archetypes are going to be in the fall so that should be fun. There are so many MORE options now because there are no decks that are TOO good now (metanite, flygon). Now, rogues probably won't have to focus all their energy on countering archetypes.

Back to back posts merged. The following information has been added:

And to every one...stock up on castaways now!!!
 
Last edited:
WE WANT LEGEND MAKER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!11!!!111

Oh well, I guess they're trying to make it easier for new players to get into the game... :nonono: we dont like u anymore new players... we dont like u :nonono:
jk

I'm still praying for a Delta Species returns set... and Admin, and Quick Search Pidgeot... :thumb:
 
We Want Jungle!

WE WANT LEGEND MAKER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!11!!!111

Oh well, I guess they're trying to make it easier for new players to get into the game... :nonono: we dont like u anymore new players... we dont like u :nonono:
jk

I'm still praying for a Delta Species returns set... and Admin, and Quick Search Pidgeot... :thumb:

..and Computer Search......and Erika...XD

Now's the time to find fast buggers capable of abusing Cessation Crystal.

Edit: Ouch, I just realized.......ApeCatty took a blow from Holon lass being rotated......ouch
 
they should remake Energy Removals, Double Colorless, Gust o Winds... man wouldnt that be a great format?

I really wanna see at Cities next yr what people are playin w/o the holon engine... Maybe DP3 will introduce the next engine??????? :confused::confused:
 
I *am* for all intents Derrick Pants. Sure I didn't have trainers worth a darn at my first Cities ... heck I was lucky to have strong pokemon lines at that point, but my Megainium d / Blastoise deck DID win one game thanks largely to the various deckbuilding guides online. Keep in mind that I bought my first card EVER on November 28th and went to my first City around the second week of December.

I had my first fully working Holon Engine with 4 Trannies by January and a second by Febuary. I held off on getting more since I had a feeling that DS would get rotated.

I take STRONG issue with the idea that cutting sets makes it "easier" on the new guy. If anything it's the reverse. He's unlikely to know which sets are legal at first and tightly resticting sets actually makes it much harder for him to figure out what to buy. There is a TON of old stuff at Target & Walmart now + on eBay the old stuff floats around like crazy.

It's not hard at all to get the cards for 1 playable deck if a newbie actually takes the time to read. Some decks are more expensive than others, so $$ will impact what he ends up with, but there are affordable decks out there. Delta is not bad. Metanite is more expensive, but does not require every single expensive tech to be a reasonable play. There are plenty of rogue decks that may not be top tier but are fine to start with while working on getting the cards for the decks you really want.

So is it hard for the new guy or is it easy?

If it's hard, then it's kind of like what you said -- all the person has to do is take the time to read up on the format a bit. But without the format change, the Holon Engine is still one of the hardest-to-get trainer sets ever. I'm glad you were able to stick around for a couple of months until you got the Holon Engine, but some people aren't so patient. If they're losing tournament after tournament not because of their Pokemon but their trainers, I can see their patience running very low. This is where money becomes a factor, and many people don't want to pull out the big bucks for uncommon trainers.

With the rotation (and a little knowledge on the format), a new player can go to the store and buy packs that will actually give them something to work with. If you bought Legend Maker packs, you were either buying them for the Stadiums or the ex's, as there's not much else to buy other than that. Same thing for Emerald. Deoxys has the unbelievably good Shinings, and Delta Species is largely bought for its trainers. The only exception to this is Unseen Forces, which has a ton of good ex's, many good holos, and many good trainers (especially the tools). The point I'm trying to make is that many sets were bought exclusively because of one good thing they had to offer (be it a nice trainer set, a nice ex set, or even a nice set of shinings). For the new player, it's hard to get these cards because of money issues. If you're having to buy an entire box of a set to get your trainers (Delta Species), where does that leave you with getting Pokemon (unless, of course, you wanted to just run MetaNite)?

A new player can buy a few packs from Dragon Frontiers and get very playable cards (7 Supporters are in the set, 10 ex's, plenty of Special Energy, and many of the rares are good) without having to consider getting the Holon Engine first and foremost. Crystal Guardians also has a lot to offer. A new player noticing that Holon Phantoms only has 3 ex's, 3 Supporters, and a low amount of Trainers will make the wise decision of not getting cards from that set. And now that Raieggs is missing the Holon Engine AND Cursed Stone (which many people failed to mention), I don't see it being that big from now on.

A new player who actually takes the time to look at the format (and setlists) a bit will make wise decisions about what cards to buy that won't lead them to a dead end. Buying cards from sets in next year's format will offer them playable items (much more so than buying LM, EM, or DX packs). The new player won't have to worry about buying DS packs exclusively for the Holon Engine, so they're free to actually buy Pokemon TCG packs for, well, Pokemon.

And from a veteran's perspective, the absence of the Holon Engine is much-needed. It's too fast, too easy to run, and it makes the game extremely linear. Of course, part of this is due to the lack of disruption in this year's format, but when an individual can play 8 trainer cards (not even Pokemon) that will get them a guaranteed bench within two turns, you're looking at a format in which things move too rapidly and many games are decided on matchups alone.

I personally feel that this is a very good decision (so good in fact that one of the game's best players has decided to return). It's good in the eyes of the veterans, and I feel it's good in the eyes of the new players.
 
Let's look at the good points of this rotation
first we won't seen any more transivers. then metanite will go and we will get to play different cards not always the holon engine. we will use different triners in our decks.
 
Back
Top